Reviews USAA Cash Rewards American Express card review
USAA Cash Rewards American Express card review

USAA Cash Rewards American Express card review

Published: August 15, 2017
Advertiser Disclosure
Ratings Policy
Cash Back Rating:
0 rating
0 rating
0 / 5
Rewards Value: 2.4
Annual Percentage Rate: 2.2
Rewards Flexibility: 3.3
Features: 4.0

In a nutshell:

The USAA Cash Rewards American Express card offers military-friendly benefits and an uncommonly low interest rate for cardholders with the best credit scores; however, its complicated tiered rewards program offers relatively little benefit. This offer is no longer available.

Rewards Rate

  • 1.45-2.25% cash back on gas and groceries
  • .45-1.25% cash back on general purchases, depending on how much you spend

Sign-up Bonus
None

Annual Fee
$0

Average Yearly Rewards Value ($1,325 monthly spend)
$259

APR
10.65-26.65% (variable)

Pros

  • Rewards don’t expire
  • No limit on amount of cash you can earn
  • Can redeem as statement credit or deposit into a USAA checking or savings account

Cons

  • Tiered rewards program is complicated and requires a large amount of spending to earn the maximum amount back
  • Won’t get full rewards rate if you redeem before you spend $17,000
  • Can’t redeem cash for gift cards, merchandise or travel

Other Notable Features: No foreign transaction fee, concierge service, car rental insurance, identity theft solutions, extended warranty, price protection, travel assistance, baggage delay insurance, trip cancellation and interruption insurance, special rates for deployment and active duty military, rebate on finance charges during military campaigns

No Annual Fee Rating:
0 rating
0 rating
0 / 5
Rewards Value: 2.9
Annual Percentage Rate: 2.0
Rewards Flexibility: 2.7
Features: 4.0

In a nutshell:

The amount that you can potentially earn on gas and groceries seems impressive, but the USAA Cash Rewards American Express card requires you to spend a lot on the card to earn the full rate, and if you redeem your rewards before you reach the spending threshold for full bonus, you lose out. This offer is no longer available.

Rewards Rate

  • 1.45-2.25% cash back on gas and groceries
  • .45-1.25% cash back on general purchases, depending on how much you spend

Sign-up Bonus
None

Annual Fee
$0

Average Yearly Rewards Value ($1,325 monthly spend)
$259

APR
10.65-26.65% (variable)

Pros

  • Rewards don’t expire
  • No limit on amount of cash you can earn
  • Can redeem as statement credit or deposit into a USAA checking or savings account

Cons

  • Tiered rewards program is complicated and requires a large amount of spending to earn the maximum amount back
  • Won’t get full rewards rate if you redeem before you spend $17,000
  • Can’t redeem cash for gift cards, merchandise or travel

Other Notable Features: No foreign transaction fee, concierge service, car rental insurance, identity theft solutions, extended warranty, price protection, travel assistance, baggage delay insurance, trip cancellation and interruption insurance, special rates for deployment and active duty military, rebate on finance charges during military campaigns

Rewards Rating:
0 rating
0 rating
0 / 5
Rewards Value: 2.1
Annual Percentage Rate: 2.7
Rewards Flexibility: 2.7
Features: 4.0

In a nutshell:

The USAA Cash Rewards American Express card offers the chance to earn a better-than-average rate on gas and groceries, but the complicated rewards tier that cardholders must navigate in order to earn the card’s highest rates probably isn’t worth the hassle. This offer is no longer available.

Rewards Rate

  • 1.45-2.25% cash back on gas and groceries
  • .45-1.25% cash back on general purchases, depending on how much you spend

Sign-up Bonus
None

Annual Fee
$0

Average Yearly Rewards Value ($1,325 monthly spend)
$259

APR
10.65-26.65% (variable)

Pros

  • Rewards don’t expire
  • No limit on amount of cash you can earn
  • Can redeem as statement credit or deposit into a USAA checking or savings account

Cons

  • Tiered rewards program is complicated and requires a large amount of spending to earn the maximum amount back
  • Won’t get full rewards rate if you redeem before you spend $17,000
  • Can’t redeem cash for gift cards, merchandise or travel

Other Notable Features: No foreign transaction fee, concierge service, car rental insurance, identity theft solutions, extended warranty, price protection, travel assistance, baggage delay insurance, trip cancellation and interruption insurance, special rates for deployment and active duty military, rebate on finance charges during military campaigns

Our reviews and best card recommendations are based on an objective rating process and are not driven by advertising dollars. However, we do receive compensation when you click on links to products from our partners. Learn more about our advertising policy

This offer is no longer available. For recent reviews, visit our reviews section.

If you need to carry a balance and can qualify for the USAA Cash Rewards American Express card’s lowest available APR, this isn’t a bad card to carry in your wallet. For cardholders with the best credit scores, it offers one of the lowest APRs available on a rewards credit card, but still manages to deliver some modest cash rewards for moderate to heavy spenders. Like all USAA credit cards, the USAA Cash Rewards American Express card also offers a range of military-friendly benefits, including an extra low APR for active duty service members.

However, cardholders with less-than-perfect credit scores should think twice before applying – especially if they plan to carry a balance. The range of possible APRs on this modest rewards card is wide, with cardholders who barely make the cut potentially getting assigned an APR as high as 26.40 percent. The USAA Cash Rewards American Express card also utilizes a complicated tiered rewards program that rewards moderate to heavy spenders with a modest cash back program, but awards next to nothing to cardholders who only use their cards occasionally.

Stingy rewards for modest spenders
The biggest drawback to the USAA Cash Rewards American Express card is its confusing tiered rewards system, which is stacked against modest and occasional spenders. For cardholders who spend less than $5,000 a year, regular purchases will earn just 0.45 percent cash back – a paltry sum compared to the 1 percent cash back that most cash back credit cards offer – while gas and grocery purchases will net 1.45 percent cash back. Meanwhile, cardholders who spend up to $10,000 a year – roughly $833 a month or less – will take in 0.45 on the first $5,000 they spend and just 0.85 percent on the next $5,000 in purchases. Grocery and gas purchases would earn 1.85 percent cash back – after cardholders spend $5,000.

Moderate to heavy spenders also get short shrift
Even moderate to heavy spenders are awarded relatively small amounts compared to what most cash back credit cards offer. To earn the standard 1 percent cash back rate on regular purchases, for example, cardholders would need to spend between $10,000 and $17,000 a year – and even then the 1 percent rewards rate would kick in only after cardholders spend $10,000.

With such a paltry sum, the most cardholders would be able to earn on regular purchases would be $135 – $35 less than a typical cash back card that offers 1 percent on general purchases would award. (Gas and grocery purchases would earn 2 percent cash back.) The card’s advertised cash back rate of 1.25 percent on general purchases and 2.25 percent on gas and groceries kicks in only after cardholders spend more than $17,000 a year. If you spend that much every year with credit, you would almost certainly be better off with a more generous card – as long as you can afford to repay your balance.

Low APR for some
Despite its less-than-generous rewards program, the USAA Cash Rewards American Express card does offer an uncommonly low rewards rate of 10.65 percent for cardholders with excellent credit, making it a still decent pick for certain types of cardholders. If you plan to carry a balance, but still want some cash back, the USAA Cash Rewards American Express card is significantly more affordable than many low rate cash back cards.

The average low interest card, for example, charges an average APR of 12.10 percent, while the average cash back card charges a minimum APR of 15.43 percent. But if your credit is imperfect, you could get hit with an unaffordable interest rate. The USAA rewards card advertises one of the widest APR ranges on the market, making it hard to guess which rate you’ll get. The card’s maximum APR of 26.65 percent is exceptionally high for any credit card and could cause cardholders’ debt to spiral out of control if they overcharge.

Hard-to-find military benefits
One of the biggest benefits of the USAA Cash Rewards American Express card is that it caters to military families. Like all USAA credit cards, it offers some of the most robust protections active duty service members can get, including a 4 percent APR on new and current debt when cardholders are deployed overseas and a rebate on interest when cardholders are awarded a qualifying medal. USAA also waives foreign transaction fees – a huge perk for military families who live abroad.

Reasons to get it:

  • You have excellent credit and are looking for a cash back card with a lower than average interest rate.
  • You’re a military service member and would benefit from the card’s protections.
  • You prefer cash back instead of points.

 How to use it:

  • To maximize the amount of cash back you receive, use your card for all or most of your purchases, including your gas and grocery purchases. The card’s biggest bonuses don’t kick in until you’ve spent a large amount.
  • Don’t carry a large balance if you’re charged a higher APR on this card. The card’s maximum rate is so high that your debt could quickly spiral out of control – especially if you only pay the minimum amount due.
  • If you’re an active duty service member, contact USAA within six months of when you return home from your deployment or when you return from a campaign for which you received a medal in order to take advantage of your benefits.

All reviews are prepared by CreditCards.com staff. Opinions expressed therein are solely those of the reviewer and have not been reviewed or approved by any advertiser. The information, including card rates and fees, presented in the review is accurate as of the date of the review. Check the data at the top of this page and the bank’s website for the most current information.

Responses to comments in the discussion section below are not provided, reviewed, approved, endorsed or commissioned by our financial partners. It is not our partner’s responsibility to ensure all posts or questions are answered.