Reviews Blue Cash card from American Express review
Blue Cash card from American Express review

Blue Cash card from American Express review

Published: July 18, 2017
Advertiser Disclosure
Ratings Policy
Cash Back Rating:
2.8 rating
2.8 rating
2.8 / 5
Rewards Value: 2.2
Annual Percentage Rate: 0.3
Rewards Flexibility: 3.4
Features: 3.0

In a nutshell:

If you can quickly reach the $6,500 annual spending requirement, the Blue Cash card from American Express offers an impressive 5 percent rate on gas and groceries with a high $50,000 annual cap and no annual fee; however, the average spender may be better off with an alternative cash back card from American Express.

Rewards Rate

  • 1% cash back on grocery, gas and drugstore purchases (on first $6,500 of spend annually)
  • 0.5% cash back on general purchases (on first $6,500 of spend annually)
  • 5% cash back on grocery, gas and drugstore purchases (on next $,6500- $50,000 of spend annually)
  • 1% cash back on general purchases (on next $,6500- $50,000 of spend annually)
  • Terms apply

Sign-up Bonus
None

Annual Fee
$0 (See rates and fees)

Average Yearly Rewards Value ($1,325 monthly spend)
$257

APR
18.24-23.24% (variable) (See rates and fees)

Rewards Redemption

Pros

  • Cash doesn’t expire
  • Can redeem for cash, gift cards or merchandise
  • High cap on grocery and gas bonus once you activate the bonus rate (up to $50,000 of card spend annually)

Cons

  • Must wait until you earn at least 2,500 points — $25 in cash — to redeem your rewards
  • Can only redeem cash as a statement credit; you can’t request a check or bank account deposit

Other Notable Features: Cash back tracker, purchase protection, return protection, entertainment access, roadside assistance, Global Assist Hotline

No Annual Fee Rating:
2.8 rating
2.8 rating
2.8 / 5
Rewards Value: 2.4
Annual Percentage Rate: 0.4
Rewards Flexibility: 3.3
Features: 3.0

In a nutshell:

You’ll have to charge a lot on the Blue Cash card from American Express to unlock the card’s 5 percent bonus on gas and groceries, but the limit on the bonus is exceptionally high, which means you could potentially earn a great bonus on gas and groceries if you spend more than average on these categories.

Rewards Rate

  • 1% cash back on grocery, gas and drugstore purchases (on first $6,500 of spend annually)
  • 0.5% cash back on general purchases (on first $6,500 of spend annually)
  • 5% cash back on grocery, gas and drugstore purchases (on next $,6500- $50,000 of spend annually)
  • 1% cash back on general purchases (on next $,6500- $50,000 of spend annually)
  • Terms apply

Sign-up Bonus
None

Annual Fee
$0 (See rates and fees)

Average Yearly Rewards Value ($1,325 monthly spend)
$257

APR
18.24-23.24% (variable) (See rates and fees)

Rewards Redemption

Pros

  • Cash doesn’t expire
  • Can redeem for cash, gift cards or merchandise
  • High cap on grocery and gas bonus once you activate the bonus rate (up to $50,000 of card spend annually)

Cons

  • Must wait until you earn at least 2,500 points — $25 in cash — to redeem your rewards
  • Can only redeem cash as a statement credit; you can’t request a check or bank account deposit

Other Notable Features: Cash back tracker, purchase protection, return protection, entertainment access, roadside assistance, Global Assist Hotline

Rewards Rating:
2.6 rating
2.6 rating
2.6 / 5
Rewards Value: 2.0
Annual Percentage Rate: 0.7
Rewards Flexibility: 3.3
Features: 3.0

In a nutshell:

Better suited for well-heeled families than cardholders on a budget, the Blue Cash card offers a generous cash back bonus on everyday purchases; but to get it, you have to clear an exceptionally high spending threshold that may be unrealistic for some families.

Rewards Rate

  • 1% cash back on grocery, gas and drugstore purchases (on first $6,500 of spend annually)
  • 0.5% cash back on general purchases (on first $6,500 of spend annually)
  • 5% cash back on grocery, gas and drugstore purchases (on next $,6500- $50,000 of spend annually)
  • 1% cash back on general purchases (on next $,6500- $50,000 of spend annually)
  • Terms apply

Sign-up Bonus
None

Annual Fee
$0 (See rates and fees)

Average Yearly Rewards Value ($1,325 monthly spend)
$257

APR
18.24-23.24% (variable) (See rates and fees)

Rewards Redemption

Pros

  • Cash doesn’t expire
  • Can redeem for cash, gift cards or merchandise
  • High cap on grocery and gas bonus once you activate the bonus rate (up to $50,000 of card spend annually)

Cons

  • Must wait until you earn at least 2,500 points — $25 in cash — to redeem your rewards
  • Can only redeem cash as a statement credit; you can’t request a check or bank account deposit

Other Notable Features: Cash back tracker, purchase protection, return protection, entertainment access, roadside assistance, Global Assist Hotline

Our reviews and best card recommendations are based on an objective rating process and are not driven by advertising dollars. However, we do receive compensation when you click on links to products from our partners. Learn more about our advertising policy

If you have a big family and spend more than a thousand dollars a month on everyday purchases, you could eventually earn a sizable return with this family-oriented cash back card. The Blue Cash card from American Express offers one of the best cash back rates available on a credit card with no annual fee.

But to earn the card’s maximum bonus, you first have to spend a substantial amount of money up front, putting the card’s best feature — a 5 percent bonus on grocery, gas and drugstore purchases — out of reach for some cardholders. Even moderate spenders will have to wait patiently before they earn more than 0.5 percent to 1 percent cash back on their purchases.

A big hurdle for some
Unless you can afford to quickly spend thousands of dollars on your card, don’t expect to earn a large amount quickly with this tiered rewards card. The Blue Cash card offers just 0.5 percent cash back on regular purchases and 1 percent cash back on groceries, gas and drugstore purchases until you spend $6,500 on your card. That means the most you’ll be able to earn for your first $6,500 in purchases is $65.

After you reach the card’s $6,500 spending threshold, you’ll start earning 5 percent cash back on groceries, gas and select drugstore purchases and 1 percent cash back on regular purchases. That’s a generous haul for a card with no annual fee; but unless you’re a voracious monthly spender, you’ll have to wait awhile to earn those sizable benefits. For a cardholder who typically spends $1,325 a month on a credit card, it could take 5 months to start earning the maximum bonus.

Modest spenders need not apply
Families on a budget could have a harder time taking full advantage of this card. If you spend just $800 a month, for example, it will take you more than eight months to clear the card’s $6,500 threshold, giving you less than four months to enjoy the 5 percent bonus before the card’s rewards calendar restarts. If you spend less than $500 a month, you won’t earn the 5 percent bonus at all. After 12 months, cardholders have to spend $6,500 again to earn the 5 percent bonus. To really get a substantial amount of benefit from this card, you need to be able to spend several thousand dollars in the first few months (or $6,500 all at once), which can be tough for many families to pull off.

No additional bonuses
The Blue Cash card doesn’t offer online applicants any sign-up bonuses either, which is surprising for a card of its caliber. Many of its competitors — including similar cards from American Express — offer new cardholders at least $100 or more in exchange for signing up. It also doesn’t contain any 0 percent promotions. Cardholders who transfer a balance or make a purchase on the card and carry over the balance will have to start paying the card’s standard APR as soon as the first billing cycle.

High APR
One of the biggest downsides to the Blue Cash card — besides its tiered rewards system — is the card’s surprisingly high APR, which is well above average for a cash back card. Cardholders with the best credit scores are offered a minimum APR of 18.24 percent, which is more than 2 percentage points higher than what the average cash back card charges. A typical cash back card, for example, charges a minimum rate of 15.60 percent, according to CreditCards.com data. Other cardholders, meanwhile, could be charged a rate as high as 23.24 percent. That means if you use your Blue Cash card for all or most of your spending, you could get hit with a substantial bill if you can’t afford to repay your purchases in full.

Better options exist for American Express fans
If you’re eager to earn a large amount of cash back on your everyday purchases and can afford to pay a significant amount of money up front, you are almost certainly better off ponying up a two-figure annual fee than spending $6,500 just to get 5 percent cash back. The American Express Blue Cash Preferred card, for example, charges a $95 annual fee and offers 6 percent cash back on grocery store purchases, 3 percent cash back on gas station and department store purchases and 1 percent cash back on regular purchases, starting from day one. Depending on how much you spend, you should be able to recoup your annual fee payment relatively quickly. You’ll also get a $150 statement credit if you spend $1,000 on the Blue Cash Preferred card within the card’s first three months.

Reasons to get it:

  • You spend a lot on groceries, drugstore and gas station purchases and want to earn a higher bonus on your everyday spending.
  • You don’t want to pay an annual fee and don’t mind waiting to earn the card’s maximum rewards.
  • You can afford to spend $6,500 relatively quickly.

How to use it:

  • Try to meet the card’s $6,500 spending threshold as quickly as possible by using your card for all or most of your everyday purchases.
  • Consider stocking up on household supplies and other pricey items you were already planning to buy within the card’s first few months.
  • Pay off your purchases in full in order to avoid paying a hefty APR.

All reviews are prepared by CreditCards.com staff. Opinions expressed therein are solely those of the reviewer and have not been reviewed or approved by any advertiser. The information, including card rates and fees, presented in the review is accurate as of the date of the review. Check the data at the top of this page and the bank’s website for the most current information.

Responses to comments in the discussion section below are not provided, reviewed, approved, endorsed or commissioned by our financial partners. It is not our partner’s responsibility to ensure all posts or questions are answered.