Stolen: True tales of identity theft

Learn how these victims worked to restore their good names and credit

Identity theft happens when you least expect it -- and it's often committed by the people you least suspect. The thief could be someone you trusted implicitly, such as your ex-girlfriend, or someone who has no qualms about living the high life on your tab.

More than 11 million U.S. adults became ID theft victims in 2009, according to a survey by Javelin Strategy & Research. Victims are fighting back, though, by filing police reports and helping to get these criminals arrested, according to the survey.    

Stolen: True tales of identity theft These true tales of identity theft attest to the frustration and heartache this type of crime can cause, as well as how these victims worked to restore their good names and credit.

ID theft victim: Bogdan Vovk
How he discovered the theft: He got a card from a jewelry store thanking him for his purchase of a Rolex watch and a diamond ring, neither of which he'd bought.
The crime: The thief posed as Vovk and went on a spending spree. He even rented an apartment and filled it with rented furniture and electronics, which he later stole. In all, he charged up more than $30,000.
The aftermath: Vovk called retailers and got the phone number the thief had provided when applying for credit. Vovk says he called and identified himself: "This is the real Bogdan Vovk." The thief replied, "No, you're not. I am," and hung up, Vovk says. Vovk then exchanged text messages with the thief, who claimed he bought Vovk's identity on the black market.
Outcome: Police arrested the thief, who pleaded guilty to identity theft and was sentenced to five years in prison. Vovk spent about 160 hours on the phone with creditors, amassed a file 8 inches thick and got every black mark erased from his credit, except for about $4,000 the thief charged at a furniture rental store. His credit score -- which he says used to be 780 -- has dropped to the 500s.
Lesson learned: If you're an identity theft victim, be proactive, get as much information as possible and turn it over to authorities. "I didn't want somebody else using what I've worked so hard to build -- it's my identity, my credit report," Vovk says. "I didn't want somebody else living my life. I wanted to put an end to it right away."

4 identity theft myths

Identity theft experts say what we don't know can hurt us. Here are some common misconceptions.

Myth No. 1: Identity theft always involves credit cards. Credit card fraud is the top category of identity theft reported to the Federal Trade Commission, but experts say a stolen identity can be used to get a job, obtain prescription drugs, have medical procedures or even get away with a crime. For example, Neal O'Farrell, executive director of the Identity Theft Council, helped a victim who went to buy cold medicine at a drug store and learned a criminal had been using his identity to do the same -- probably to make meth.

Myth No. 2: You don't have to worry about ID theft if you have bad credit. "Identity theft does happen to people who have bad credit or no credit," says personal security and identity theft expert Robert Siciliano. "All you need to become a victim of identity theft is a Social Security number."  Sometimes a thief doesn't even need that. O'Farrell helped an elderly couple whose names and address had been plucked from a phone book and printed on fake checks with a fake bank account number.

Myth No. 3: Using a credit monitoring service will prevent you from becoming an ID theft victim. "Because of all the hype around these services, a lot of consumers think they're safe, but nothing can make you completely safe," says Linda Foley, an identity theft victim and founder of the Identity Theft Resource Center. "A credit monitoring service won't show you if someone is using your existing credit card or if they've gotten speeding tickets in your name."

Myth No. 4: If you become a victim, you need to hire a lawyer. "Most attorneys do not know how to take care of identity theft unless this is an area they specialize in," Foley says. "You don't usually need an attorney unless something goes really bad and you have a credit reporting agency stepping all over your rights."

ID theft victim: Don Redinius
How he discovered the theft:
After a break-up, he moved, filed a change of address form at the post office and began receiving credit card statements his ex had been intercepting when they lived together.
What the thief did:
She used his Bank of America and Citi credit cards to pay for spa facials, massages and even a Caribbean cruise -- racking up more than $68,000 in debt. She also intercepted a blank check from a financial services company, opened the line of credit in Redinius' name, forged his signature and sent the $6,000 to her family in Greece.
The aftermath:
Redinius filed several police reports, alerted the Federal Trade Commission and wrote a letter to the Arizona attorney general. Redinius estimates that he has spent at least 300 hours on the phone with creditors. He has resolved two of the accounts and is still working on the third.
After several years, the thief has not been prosecuted. "It's a white-collar crime, not very exciting," to police, Redinius says. "They don't fly helicopters over the house where the ID theft occurred or go after the thief in a high-speed chase -- yet it's a very significant problem." Because financial problems can precede identity theft, as was the case with his ex, Redinius wrote a personal finance book, "The New Era of Financial Success."
Lesson learned:
"Don't be so trusting of people, especially as it relates to financial things," Redinius says. "My financial information used to be more open around people I thought I could trust. In fact, I think the way she got my credit card number for Citibank was, I remember throwing that stuff in a dresser drawer. Now I'm much more careful." 

ID theft victim: Jessica Guberman
How she discovered the theft:
She was getting ready to go on a camping trip in Vermont with her husband when an investigator from her local police department knocked on her door and asked to question her about an ID theft ring.
What the thief did: The thief or thieves opened multiple credit cards in Guberman's name and used them to buy more than $14,000 worth of clothes and expensive jewelry. "They bought a lot of engagement rings and Ralph Lauren clothes," Guberman says. A year later, they hacked into her bank account and stole $17,000 -- which she discovered on her birthday when she went to pay for a massage and her debit card was declined. When she got home, her husband told her he'd tried to buy her flowers, but his card had been declined, too. There were 10 cents left in the account.
The aftermath: Guberman's once-excellent credit score crashed. "I had 11 or 12 credit cards, they were all maxed out. I had never made a payment, and they were all in collections," she says. She made hundreds of phone calls to resolve the problem and restore her good credit. She put a seven-year fraud alert and a freeze on her credit report.
Outcome: Police never learned who was behind the identity theft or how the thief got Guberman's information, but they told her there were about a dozen other victims in her area. Guberman never got her money back from the bank.
Lesson learned: Consider a credit freeze, which is available to anyone and prevents credit bureaus from providing your credit report to new lenders without your approval. "It's a minor inconvenience, but it's worth it," Guberman says.

See related: When hit by ID theft, take these 4 steps to make things right, Survey: 28 perent of ID theft victims know crime source, Credit card video: 6 tips to protect yourself from ID theft, New survey finds most common ID theft victims, Put your credit report on ice with a credit freeze

Join the discussion
We encourage an active and insightful conversation among our users. Please help us keep our community civil and respectful. For your safety, do not disclose confidential or personal information such as bank account numbers or social security numbers. Anything you post may be disclosed, published, transmitted or reused.

If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the 'Post to Facebook' box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.

The editorial content on is not sponsored by any bank or credit card issuer. The journalists in the editorial department are separate from the company's business operations. The comments posted below are not provided, reviewed or approved by any company mentioned in our editorial content. Additionally, any companies mentioned in the content do not assume responsibility to ensure that all posts and/or questions are answered.

Weekly newsletter
Get the latest news, advice, articles and tips delivered to your inbox. It's FREE.

Updated: 11-23-2017