Opening Credits

When new to credit, top rewards cards may be out of reach


A student about to graduate wants a top-tier travel rewards card to be her first card, but her short credit history may not let her qualify – yet. Here are the steps to take.

The content on this page is accurate as of the posting date; however, some of our partner offers may have expired. Please review our list of best credit cards, or use our CardMatch™ tool to find cards matched to your needs.

Dear Opening Credits,
I am looking to get my first credit card. I am currently a full-time student, but will be graduating in December. I would like to travel when I graduate. I would like to open a credit card to start earning points toward travel rewards now.

I have looked up my credit score using two free sites, which reported my score as 703 and 712. I have done some research and the best travel rewards cards seem to be the Chase Sapphire Preferred and the Barclaycard Arrival. With a short credit history consisting almost entirely of student loans, and as a first-time applicant, I do not know if either of these will be good choices for me, or if I even have a chance at getting approved.

Furthermore, since I don’t currently spend money on travel, would it be wiser to apply for a general rewards card and later open a travel card and transfer the points? I have also heard that there are so many cards that don’t have an annual fee, that I should avoid cards that have them. Sorry for all the questions, but I am feeling a bit overwhelmed with all of the options! — Kylie

Dear Kylie,
Shopping for plastic can be a little like trying to decide on what to order at a restaurant with a particularly large menu. What should you order when so much looks delicious? And which dishes are best for you? Time to narrow down the choices!

I love that you want to start with the best card right from the beginning. It’s great that you appreciate the benefits of a premium product. Many cards come with travel-related perks, such as the ability to earn points for free trips, free checked bags and priority boarding. A few even open the doors to VIP airport lounges all over the world.

To qualify for such wondrous cards, though, you’ll have to meet the credit issuer’s standards. Here’s what they look for in a cardholder:

High credit scores. Issuers use FICO scores to determine an applicant’s risk level. These scores start at a low of 300 and top out at 850. Assuming the free scores you got  use that same range, and it’s accurate, you are in the “good” range between 700 and 749. And I must commend you because even though you’re just starting out, they are impressive. You must have been treating your financial obligations well, perhaps by paying an unsubsidized portion of your student loans on time or keeping a car loan in positive standing.

Unfortunately, your scores are not high enough to qualify for the credit cards you’ve identified. In fact, they would have to be in the best scoring category, which is called “excellent,” of 750 and above. Since your digits are a little short, I would avoid applying for these cards. Chances are you’ll get the “sorry, try again later” message — along with a small credit score deduction that is a byproduct of applying for credit.

Sufficient income. Issuers don’t usually publish exact income requirements for each credit card, but what you make is certainly a factor in approval. If the card has a very low limit, you probably won’t need to be earning much, but if it’s a large limit you most likely do.

Both of the cards you mentioned offer credit lines that start in the thousands, so they would require an income that can support the type of debt you can get into. To qualify, you’ll first need to secure a well-paying job and hold it for at least a year.

If it sounds like I’m dissuading you from trying for these accounts, I’m not. You just need to delay your application until you’re in a more-attractive position.

In the meantime (and after you get a job), start with a card that is within reach. There are plenty of fantastic accounts available to people with scores like yours.

Because you’re not traveling immediately, you may as well go for a more general rewards card for which you already qualify, so you can earn points for cash back plus travel perks. And yes, avoid cards with annual fees.

After you have a card, use it perfectly for a year. That means charging on a regular basis, but paying your bill in full and on time every month. By doing so, your scores will rise, points will accumulate and the odds of you being approved for even more desirable accounts escalate. Then you can put the credit menu down and concentrate on managing both accounts, reaping the rewards each provides.

See related: When you can, can’t transfer reward points, Credit card application rejected? 3 steps to getting the next one approved

Editorial Disclaimer

The editorial content on this page is based solely on the objective assessment of our writers and is not driven by advertising dollars. It has not been provided or commissioned by the credit card issuers. However, we may receive compensation when you click on links to products from our partners.

What’s up next?

In Opening Credits

How leaving a tiny card balance each month affects credit score

Keeping the balance-to-credit ratio low, paying in full and on time is a better way to get the most from your secured card.

See more stories
Credit Card Rate Report
Cash Back

Questions or comments?

Contact us

Editorial corrections policies

Learn more