Is it time for a holiday credit card swap?


Between gifts, holiday travel and year-end expenses, the holidays are a good opportunity to score major rewards using the right credit card. Just make sure you meet minimum spends, avoid fees and don’t carry a balance.

The content on this page is accurate as of the posting date; however, some of our partner offers may have expired. Please review our list of best credit cards, or use our CardMatch™ tool to find cards matched to your needs.

Savvy shoppers are already stockpiling holiday gifts and prepping for the season of red and green. And while you are spending all of that green in the weeks ahead, a rewards card can pay you a little back or fill your holiday sack with miles and points.

Maybe it’s time for a holiday card swap to rack up rewards on your spending from now through New Year’s Day. Maybe stuffing another rewards card in your stocking (though your wallet would be more practical), would bring in more points, miles or cash back than the cards you are using for your everyday spending now.

“Banks are really fighting over customers, trying to come up with richer and more innovative offers,” such as generous sign-up bonuses, says Marc Bellanger, senior strategy director for Merkle, a marketing agency serving the banking and credit card industry.

Most of those sign-up bonuses require cardholders to spend a minimum amount within the first few months. However, between gifts, holiday travel and year-end expenses, the holidays are one time of year that your plastic sees a lot of action. So why not use it to your advantage – and get a nice reward?

Here are five things to keep in mind to execute a successful holiday card swap:

5 tips to a successful holiday card swap

1. Look for flexible card rewards.

David Rae recently used card rewards to score two free first-class tickets to Europe – saving $25,000.

But as a certified financial planner, Rae also wants consumers to be smart about rewards.

If you want to turn your points into flights, hotel stays or merchandise, look for a card that allows you to shop around for those items – and doesn’t lock you into one carrier or hotel, says Rae, president and founder of DRM Wealth Management.

Comparison shopping means better deals, whether you’re spending cash or rewards.

One card he likes: Chase Ink Business Preferred, which offers an 80,000-point bonus, and a lot of flexibility in how you can use them.

Also, look for a card with a rewards redemption structure that fits your needs. Some cash back cards, for instance, will set a minimum redemption amount of $25 or will only let you redeem rewards as credit statements, while others will let you redeem cash back for any amount, any time, even as a gift card.

2. You don’t have to pay an annual fee.

While some rewards or cash back cards waive the annual fee for the first year, there are plenty of cards that don’t have an annual fee at all.

If your credit card waives the annual fee for the first year but won’t for the second, you can also switch cards.

“I, myself, switch cards every year,” says Michelle Madhok, publisher of the shopping site She sets a calendar reminder to cancel the old card – and gets those new-card bonuses without paying an annual fee.

“Banks are really fighting over customers, trying to come up with richer and more innovative offers.”

3. Take advantage of rotating categories.

While some cards reward you with the same rewards rate year-round, others give bonus points on rotating categories that might come in especially handy around the holidays.

Rae delayed one purchase a couple of days because, starting Oct. 1, the item would earn 5 percent rewards, instead of 1 percent. “I’m cognizant of those deadlines,” he says.

The other deadline to remember: The one on the minimum spending threshold for that sign-up bonus.

If that date is approaching and you’re just a few dollars short? Pick up gift cards for the grocery store or other places you frequently shop, says Rae.

Or you can pay bills (such as your cellphone, insurance or utilities), in advance, says Madhok. But first make sure providers don’t charge “convenience fees” for using a credit card. Often a percentage of the transaction, those can negate any value you make in points.

And never put more on the card than you can repay in one month.

Even rewards “are not worth having credit card debt,” says Rae. “The points are nice, and they can be very valuable. But credit card debt is very expensive.”

Video: Credit card reward hacks

4. Prioritize the new rewards card.

If you want to accrue rewards without additional spending, the trick is to substitute the card for places you might be using cash, debit cards or checks.

That could mean everything from gas to groceries to utilities. “Put it in your wallet and use it for your regular spending,” says Rae, who also sets up the new rewards card to autopay many bills.

One challenge with this approach: When you use cash and debit cards, the money is gone from your account the minute you spend it. With credit, you have the illusion of still having money that you’ve actually spent, especially during the holidays, when expenses can quickly pile up. This could be problematic when you go to pay the bill.

Keep track of your card balance as you buy (via a phone app or small notebook). And earmark that amount to pay off your card balance. That way, no ugly surprises when that bill arrives. And most cards allows you (check with the issuer) to make payments several times a month.

Before you select a rewards card, make sure the spending threshold required for any bonus is realistic for you.

While spending $500 within three months would be fairly easy for anyone with a gas tank and a refrigerator, spending $4,000 within the same time period won’t suit everyone’s budget. And it could easily lead to overspending on holiday gifts and other seasonal expenses.

“Look at your past spending to see what your trend is on your existing card,” says Bellanger. Is the bonus requirement a comfortable goal?

5. Rewards are for cardholders who don’t carry a balance.

If you’re the person who puts holiday spending on the cards and pays it off over a few months, the credit card rewards game isn’t for you.

Credit card interest rates on rewards cards, which has tracked weekly since 2007, are consistently higher than average credit card rates. That means paying a month of interest pretty much guts the value of any rewards you accrue. Paying more in interest than you’re earning in rewards is a losing proposition.

If you carry a balance or expect to in the next few months, a better move might be to “find a nice 18-month or longer 0-percent balance transfer offer,” says Bellanger. “You’ll save money over the long term.”

After all, you don’t want to spend the new year digging out of credit card debt you piled up buying all the fixings for your family Thanksgiving dinner, charging a sleigh full of gifts for friends and family and jetting off to New York City to see the Rockettes’ Radio City Christmas Spectacular.

See related: Merry early holiday shopping: 6 ways to cut your costs now, How to maximize credit card rewards while holiday shopping, Is it time for a rewards card reboot?

Editorial Disclaimer

The editorial content on this page is based solely on the objective assessment of our writers and is not driven by advertising dollars. It has not been provided or commissioned by the credit card issuers. However, we may receive compensation when you click on links to products from our partners.

What’s up next?

In Rewards

Cyber Monday 2017: 10 hacks to score great deals

Pre-scout deals, get an electronic heads-up on special buys and scrub your computer before you shop. Now you’re ready to save big on Cyber Monday 2017

See more stories
Credit Card Rate Report
Cash Back

Questions or comments?

Contact us

Editorial corrections policies

Learn more