Inform customer before your business runs card number on file
Ask a question.
Dear Your Business Credit,
We are an engineering firm. Our customers typically make a down payment with a credit card for their drawings at the beginning, then when the drawings are final, they pay with a credit card for the final payment.
We worked recently with a customer on a project that started in March and closed in May. Both times his credit card transaction went through without any problem.
I note on every invoice with each payment who authorized the credit card transaction. On Aug. 10, this same customer requested that my boss travel clear over to Wilson, Wyoming, from Rexburg, Idaho, to do an inspection for him. My boss did and gave him the verbal information that he needed.
When my boss got back to the office, I called the client to collect payment and he gave me a credit card number to run. I read it back like I always do. I tried it several times and it kept coming back, "bad number."
I called him back immediately and he said that he had already left the office and asked me to call back in the morning. I did, and several times throughout the day, and the following days, all with no answer, even calling from different lines hoping the caller ID wouldn't show our name.
Since he gave me a bogus number to run on this open invoice, is it legal for me to run the card that we still have on file that went through before just fine? I will be looking forward to hearing from you. – Jeanine
This situation is a bit tricky. Given that you have worked with this customer before and his previous transactions went through with no problem, I’m not certain that he was trying to commit fraud. It’s possible that he made an honest mistake in giving you the what he thought was the correct credit card number and then faced an urgent personal situation after talking with you, such as a medical problem, that took precedence over getting you a new card number. Since this is a possibility, be tactful in how you interact with him.
That said, your company does need to get paid – particularly given the efforts your boss made to be accommodating. I asked Leslie Tayne, an attorney in Melville, New York, who specializes in small business debt and credit, if it would be OK for you to run the charges through on the other card.
“I would try to get authorization from the consumer for the card on file and send a letter in writing to them that this is now outstanding and that you will be charging the card you have on file,” Tayne suggested in an email. “Since there is a card on file, I would run that once you send out the letter.”
You’ve already tried to get authorization to no avail, so it seems your next step is to send the letter explaining your intentions. If your customer intends to pay and has access to his mail at the moment, he’ll probably pick up the phone and call you with the new credit card number. I’d give him a few days. If there’s still no check in the mail, then you may want to act on Tayne’s advice and run the credit card. Your customer may not be happy about it, but if he complains, remind him about the efforts you made to reach him. A reasonable person will understand that your company needed to get paid.
Meet CreditCards.com's reader Q&A experts
Does a personal finance problem have you worried? Monday through Saturday, CreditCards.com's Q&A experts answer questions from readers. Ask a question, or click on any expert to see their previous answers.
- What are the business implications of switching to an EIN from a SSN? – Switching to an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from a Social Security Number (SSN) can have security, tax and business implications. Here's what you need to know ...
- How can I cancel my merchant agreement without incurring fees? – If you want to want to cancel your merchant service provider agreement without paying termination fees, start by reading, and understanding, your contract's fine print ...
- What happens to my credit accounts after selling my business? – Make sure to close any credit accounts associated with your business and pay off any card debt. This will help you keep your credit intact and add value to the business you're selling ...