Example shows switching credit cards has become costly
An average balance, transferred in today's market runs about $235
Switching credit cards once was easy and inexpensive, but has become less so, especially for people with less-than-perfect credit. The example below shows that for a person who has many of the average characteristics of a credit card shopper in the market that exists in early 2009, the cost is estimated at about $235 for a person with a $7,300 credit card balance. The calculation factors in the balance transfer fee and time involved in looking for a new credit card.
|What's the cost of transferring a balance?|
|When balance transfers were everywhere and fee-free, it was quick and easy and an automatic financial win to jump between cards. Today, with credit tightening and balance transfer fees common, the math has changed. CreditCards.com calculated the cost of one such transfer, using examples as close to today's real-life market as possible.|
|Balance transfer fee|
|Upfront balance transfer fee of 3%
||Amount transferred||Fee (3%)
|Expenditure of time costs|
||Time (in hours)
||Hourly wage rate||Cost|
|Time spent changing 2 recurring automatic payments from old card to new (via Internet)||0.17||$18.79||$3.13|
|Time spent applying for new credit card online||0.17||$18.79||$3.13|
|Time spent evaluating direct mail or online credit card offers to choose the best card for your needs||0.50||$18.79||$9.40|
|Notes, methodology, assumptions|
Whether switching your credit card will cost anything close to the example outlined above -- and whether that nets out to be a moneymaker -- depends on a number of factors. Among them:
Methodology and assumptions: For the transfer amount, we used a credit card with an outstanding balance of $7,300, the average amount of credit card debt in 2007 according to the Consumer Finances Survey published by the Federal Reserve in February 2009.
This example assumes the consumer is making two payments a month using recurring automatic payments to the old card. A study released by the Federal Reserve in October 2008 says the number of payments initiated on billers' sites is unknown. However, rewards card users frequently sign up for such payment methods to boost spending for rewards points.
Time cost: What is the value of your time? The closest estimate is what workers are paid by employers. According to the U.S. Department of Labor's Bureau of Labor Statistics, the average wage for a nonfarm, production nonsupervisory worker was $18.49 in January 2009.
For information on your particular situation, see our Balance transfer calculator.
- Guide to American Express 'Pay It Plan It' – "Pay It Plan It" is a flexible payment option offered by American Express in some personal credit cards. Is it worth it? Here's everything you need to know, including fees and tips ...
- 2019 Balance Transfer Card Survey: APRs soar, but no-fee options abound – Balance transfer credit card seekers have more options to avoid paying a fee to shift debt between cards, according to a new CreditCards.com survey. However, rising APRs make it critical to pay off a transferred balance in a timely manner ...
- Can you really win the balance transfer game? – Many consumers turn to balance transfer offers to work their way out of debt. Unfortunately, they don't always pan out the way we want. Here's how to win the balance transfer game ...