Goodbye, checks: States benefits move to direct deposit, debit cards
Programs, fees vary widely: 9 things to know
By Amy Buttell Crane | Published: November 18, 2010
Following the federal government's lead, state governments are migrating more payments -- for everything from unemployment to child support -- away from paper checks.
But while some experts hail the move to debit cards and direct deposit as safe and convenient for consumers, it also brings a list of rules, restrictions and fees that can trip up consumers who don't do their homework.
The movement away from getting government payments via checks is clear. The federal goverment soon will mandate that payments be received by direct deposit or debit card. For recipients of state benefits and state-administered payments, the same holds true: For many, debit cards and direct deposit are now the only ways to receive payments.
For the states, the switch is largely about cutting costs. They are partnering with bank or card transaction companies to manage these programs.
Experts say the move holds benefits for the consumer as well. "Not only is there a significant cost savings associated with the use of these cards for state governments, but there are also security issues," says Dave Turner, senior vice president, government solutions at ACS, a division of Xerox that provides debit card services to state and federal government agencies. "Checks can get lost or stolen, or people may not have access to their mail in the event of a natural disaster. It's much more convenient to have a card you can keep with you."
Here are nine things you should know if you currently receive or might soon receive a state-sponsored debit card for your state benefits or state administered payments:
1. Your payments are automatically loaded on your card. Virtually all state agencies will issue a card once without charge, and automatically reload the benefits on that card at regular intervals when payments are issued or administered.
2. Use the card at retail stores to purchase items and get free cash back. By far, the best places to use your debit card are at retail stores where you can use the card without a fee and get free cash back.
3. Check your balance online or via a toll-free customer service number. In most cases, you'll have to pay a fee to check your balance at an ATM, although some states do allow free balance inquiry checks at affiliated ATMs. For example, Pennsylvania EPPI card users, who are recipients of child support payments, can get their balances free at Wells Fargo/Wachovia ATMs. Also, many states limit the number of balance inquiries you can make over the phone to four or five per month and charge $1 or so for every additional inquiry.
4. You'll pay a fee if you need a replacement. That fee is typically $5 -- if you can wait to get the card via first class mail. But if you're stuck and need overnight delivery, it can cost as much as $15 to $25 extra for the replacement.
5. Beware overdraft fees. In many states, you can only spend as much as the benefit that is placed on your card by a state agency. But in some states, you get charged a substantial overdraft fee if you overdraw your card.
6. Sign up for alerts. If you enroll in your state's online banking program, you may be able to sign up for alerts about low balances and deposits.
7. ATM withdrawals may be limited. In Oklahoma, recipients of unemployment insurance payments get two free ATM withdrawals per month at Bank of Oklahoma. Other programs push consumers toward a specific bank's ATMs. For example, New York Direct Payment debit card recipients can make free cash withdrawals at Chase ATMs, but they only get one free withdrawal per month elsewhere. Some beneficiaries get no free ATM withdrawals. Typical fees for each ATM withdrawal after free benefits are used run from 90 cents to $2 per withdrawal. There may also be individual bank surcharges for such ATM withdrawals.
8. Watch out for programs with special rules. If you receive food assistance, you can only use your card to purchase certain types of items. Also, some states automatically roll over unused benefits from one month to another but cancel benefits that aren't used within 365 days. Several states will charge you a fee for using a card that is inactive.
9. Use tellers wisely. Some programs allow you to get free cash from bank, credit union and savings and loan tellers. However, these services are usually limited to certain specific institutions or banks that are affiliated with certain payment systems, such as MasterCard. Go outside that network to get a cash withdrawal via a teller and you'll pay a fee.
|Examples: Fees you pay when the state pays you with plastic|
|State program||ATM cash withdrawal||Balance inquiry||Card replacement||Cash teller withdrawal|
|Georgia EPPICard Debit MasterCard||$1.25 at Wells Fargo ATMs||No charge at a Wells Fargo ATM||$5 for regular mail; $15 more for overnight mail||Free at banks and credit unions affiliated with MasterCard|
|New York Direct Payment MasterCard Debit Card||Free at Chase and AllPoint ATMs; one free withdrawal per deposit at other ATMs; $1.50 fee per transaction after that||Free at Chase and AllPoint ATMs; .50 cents at other ATMs and ATM surcharge fee may apply; no charge for online or toll-free customer service balance inquiries||One free replacement card per year; $5 per card thereafter; $10 more for overnight delivery||Free at banks and credit unions affiliated with MasterCard|
|North Dakota ReliaCard Debit Visa||Free at U.S. Bank or MoneyPass ATMs; $1.25 per transaction at other ATMs||Free||Free via regular mail; $15 for expedited mail||Free|
|Oklahoma EPPICard Debit MasterCard||$1.35 each after two free at Bank of Oklahoma with each deposit||50 cents per ATM inquiry; 5 free calls, then 50 cents each; free online||$4 for regular mail; $14 more for overnight mail||Free|
|Pennsylvania EPPICard Debit MasterCard||$1.10 per withdrawal||Free online; 50 cents per inquiry at an ATM; six free inquiries per month via toll-free customer service; subsequent calls are 25 cents each||$5 for regular mail; $15 more for overnight mail||Free through banks or credit unions affiliated with MasterCard|
|Texas Chase Debit Visa||Free at Chase ATMs; one withdrawal per deposit at other ATMs, $1.50 fee per transaction thereafter||No charge at Chase ATM; 50 cents per inquiry at other ATMs; free online||One free replacement card per year; $7.50 per card thereafter; $10 more for expedited mail||One free withdrawal per deposit at Chase or banks affiliated with Visa|
- Bonus card rewards for mobile payments aim to win over users – While credit cards have long vied to be top of wallet, issuers now aim to be a cardholder's default payment app, too ...
- Plastiq, Tio: Pros, cons of charging your bills through an online service – Services such as Plastiq and Tio let you charge many bills you'd otherwise have to pay straight from your bank account. But their fees range between 1.9 and 2.5 percent of each transaction ...
- Gift cards: What to do when retailer files for bankruptcy – If a retailer is on shaky financial ground, use that gift card while you can, experts say ...