Reward card sign-up bonuses not all created equal
A hotel card's 100,000 points often worth less than other card bonuses
Rewards expert who writes the "Cashing In" reader Q&A column for CreditCards.com
If you’re a fan of receiving big bonuses of reward points, chances are you’ve noticed some of the generous offers lately on hotel credit cards. Before you race to sign up for a hotel credit card, though, make sure you understand how hotel points systems work: The offers might be less lucrative than they appear.
Currently, hotel cards are offering some of the biggest caches of points out there:
- The Hilton Honors Surpass card from American Express (current annual fee: $75 before Jan. 18, 2018; $95 thereafter) is offering 125,000 Hilton points: 100,000 for spending $3,000 in the first three months, plus another 25,000 for spending an additional $1,000 in the first six months.
- Another big offer is with the Chase Marriott Rewards Premier card (current annual fee: $85, waived first year). The Marriott card is offering 10 points on every dollar spent in the first year, up to $12,000, which means you can earn up to 120,000 Marriott points.
Those are big hauls of points. Typically with reward cards, you’ll see sign-up bonuses of around 50,000 points. Occasionally, bonuses will hit 100,000. Seeing multiple offers of more than 100,000 points is unusual.
However, keep in mind that all points are not created equal. Each rewards program – those run by banks, airlines, hotels and so on – essentially has its own currency. You earn points or miles for certain activities, including charging money on a credit card, and you redeem those miles or points for other activities, such as cash back, flights or hotel stays.
Compare the value of hotel points at various properties
Getting excited about 100,000 points or more might not be justified if you’re not getting a great value for those points. Let’s look more closely at how you might use 125,000 Hilton points from that card offer.
Hilton does not have a set award chart, but rather tells you on a case-by-case basis how many points are required based on room availability and other factors.
Let’s say you’re going to New Orleans for a night in early December. Looking on Hilton’s website, you see 25 different options. The most expensive is The Roosevelt, a luxury hotel near the French Quarter, which goes for $212 a night or 56,000 points. The least expensive is the Hampton Inn in Covington, an hour north of New Orleans, which goes for $90 a night or 19,000 points.
If you redeemed your 125,000 points at The Roosevelt, they would be worth $473. If you redeemed your 125,000 points at the Hampton Inn in Covington, they would be worth $592.
That’s not bad: Either way, you’re receiving hundreds of dollars in value from the card in the form of a couple nights at a fancy hotel or six nights at a suburban Hampton Inn.
Calculate points value for a big sign-up bonus
But don’t think that 125,000 points in the Hilton program are as valuable as 125,000 points in other programs.
If you had 125,000 airline miles, that’s generally worth five domestic coach round-trips or two coach round-trips to Europe, which could be worth $2,000 or more. If you had 125,000 Chase points and a Chase Sapphire Reserve card, you could redeem those Chase points for travel worth $1,875.
The bottom line: Don’t be wowed by large numbers of reward points. Before signing up for any reward card, check out the program and ensure you understand how points are earned and spent. In the case of hotel cards, reward currencies are often worth less than those of other programs.
See related: Maximizing card rewards after you’ve earned the sign-up bonus, Hotel credit card reviews, How to get free stays and perks faster with hotel rewards, 5 ways hotel cards add up to big savings
- 5 times when a no annual fee card is worth it – High-end credit cards come with a lot of perks, but sometimes a no annual fee card can offer what you really need ...
- Ikea, Apple and other big brand cards are not great for rewards – If you're a fan of a certain brand, you may be tempted to sign-up for their credit card to earn points toward future purchases. But, many of the big brand cards don't offer as much in rewards as a straight travel or cash back card ...
- Hotel cards: Get the most free nights for the fewest points – Hotel cards can offer some valuable redemption rates, but they're not as straightforward as airline points. Know which hotels give you the most free nights for the fewest points ...