Credit Smart

To escape from crummy cards, you need a plan


Get basic good credit behavior down pat; worry about the nuances later

The content on this page is accurate as of the posting date; however, some of our partner offers may have expired. Please review our list of best credit cards, or use our CardMatch™ tool to find cards matched to your needs.

QuestionDear Credit Smart,
I am about to be in a position where I can pay off two of my credit cards. I have one with a 36 percent interest rate and my newest card set to pay off. But my 36 percent interest rate card also has a monthly fee, so I will continue to pay it even if I don’t have a balance. I also want to close my accounts after I pay them off. I know me and I will use them if I have an open balance. But the problem is, my 36 percent interest rate is also my oldest card. Should I just pay off my two newer cards and close them? Will that hurt my credit as much as closing my oldest card? Thanks for your help! – Michael


Dear Michael,
It’s great that you have the ability to pay off a good portion of your debt now. It’s also encouraging to hear that you know yourself well enough to know that having credit available to you is not necessarily a good thing.

What I have an issue with is your decision to keep a card that not only charges you an exorbitant interest rate (36 percent!) but, to add insult to injury, also charges you an annual fee. Oldest card or not, I would strongly suggest that this is the card you should not only pay off, but close and sever ties with immediately.

You are correct that your credit score looks at the age of your accounts and having older accounts is generally a good thing. But when you weigh the costs, I would say that it’s just not worth it. The only way you might consider keeping it is if you can convince your creditor to lower the rate and either eliminate or lower the annual fee. Because you are a long-time customer, it is probably worth a phone call to ask for a lower credit card rate. You will need to speak with a supervisor and make it clear that you will be closing the account unless you can get some concession from them. They may not work with you and if they

don’t, you need to follow through and close the account.

What you can do to bolster your score if you close this account is to use the remaining cards in a responsible manner. I know you are concerned about having open credit and the temptation to use it, but I hope you will consider this option. Here is what I would suggest you do. Pay off that 36 percent card and be done with it and then pay off the card with the next highest interest rate. Then you need to concentrate on paying off that third card as soon as you can.

Depending on the rate you have for the second card, you might want to leave that one open. Closing multiple accounts will decrease your available credit, which is another factor in credit scoring. Until you have paid off that third card, you can tell yourself that both of those cards are closed. Take it out of your wallet for now if that will help. Don’t add any more to the third card until it is paid off as well.

Once you are out from under your credit card debt, use your cards for everyday purchases that you would normally pay for in

cash. The trick here is to put that money aside so that when the bill comes you are able to pay it in full when it is due. This is a responsible use of credit that will both keep your accounts (and available credit) open and show consistent on-time payments, which will help both your credit score and your overall financial health.

Remember to always use your credit smarts!

See related:How average account age affects your credit score, FICO’s 5 factors: the components of a credit score


Editorial Disclaimer

The editorial content on this page is based solely on the objective assessment of our writers and is not driven by advertising dollars. It has not been provided or commissioned by the credit card issuers. However, we may receive compensation when you click on links to products from our partners.

What’s up next?

In Credit Smart

10 business card mistakes that can tank your credit

A low score can make it difficult to secure loans, retain suppliers and attract customers.

See more stories
Credit Card Rate Report
Cash Back

Questions or comments?

Contact us

Editorial corrections policies

Learn more