Why an old debt may vanish from credit report
Don't celebrate yet; it's probably temporary
By Barry Paperno | Published: May 26, 2016
Speaking of Credit
Dear Speaking of Credit,
I noticed a collection account came off my credit report, and the account is 4 years old. Is it possible that it came off only because a new collection agency bought the debt? Could it reappear on my credit report soon? – Scott
If a new agency recently bought the 4-year-old collection debt, then yes, it’s possible that recent changes to how the credit bureau reports the debt – new agency name and contact information, for example – could be responsible for its unexpected removal. And yes, in this situation I would expect it to return to your credit report sometime soon.
Fortunately, when the debt returns to your credit report with the new owner’s information, the account should continue to reflect the same “assigned” or “open” date that, along with the date the debt first became delinquent, helps determine the length of time the account will remain on your credit report.
In addition to this possibility, there are a few other scenarios that could explain why it vanished from your credit report:
Falling through the cracks
Have you or a credit repair company acting on your behalf disputed that collection with any of the credit bureaus? If so, there could be a more likely explanation.
For years, using a less-than-ethical credit repair practice called “jamming,” many consumers and credit repair agencies have been able to temporarily remove negative-but-accurate credit bureau information. They take advantage of a legal requirement that gives the collection agency 30 days to reply to a bureau’s request for verification that the debt belongs to the consumer. If that requirement is not met and no reply is received within 30 days, the item must be removed from the credit report.
The “jamming” refers to the consumer or credit repair company disputing everything. They file multiple disputes of all negative item as “not mine” in hopes that eventually the collection agency will fail to respond within the allotted time and trigger removal of the item from the credit report. The thinking here is that the more disputes there are to be investigated, the greater the likelihood of a consumer dispute verification falling through the cracks at the collection agency, credit bureau or somewhere in between.
A major downside for the consumer when using this tactic is that, even when successful, the collection is likely to reappear on the credit report at a later date when re-reported by the collection agency.
Not being reported at all three credit bureaus
Unlike most creditors that report credit accounts to all three major credit bureaus, some collection agencies report to only one or two of the three largest credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian and TransUnion). In this case, you shouldn’t expect to see the collection on all of your credit reports.
In your observation that the collection is now missing from your credit report, are you sure you have been comparing credit reports from the same credit bureau? Have you looked at your credit reports from all three credit bureaus? If not, there is a good chance that the missing collection may have never been reported to all three credit bureaus in the first place. This, of course, would not be a bad thing for your credit at the bureau not reporting it.
If you haven’t already done so, be sure to order your latest credit reports from any of the three bureaus that you may not have checked recently by going to AnnualCreditReport.com.
Reported using an old address
Another possible answer to the missing collection question is that, when first reported, the collection agency may have supplied the credit bureau with only your name and an old, perhaps even temporary, address. Neither a Social Security number nor date of birth is required for reporting collections to a credit bureau.
When this occurs a split file can result, due to a lack of sufficient identifying information attached to the collection at the bureau. With a split file, you would essentially have one main file containing all or most of your other credit information and another consisting of only this collection. Unless you or a creditor provide that old address as a previous address in any credit report requests, the collection is likely to be left out of the report you or the creditor receive.
To obtain all of your credit information under these circumstances, simply include the address associated with the collection as a previous address when requesting your credit report.
So, regardless of the reason for its removal, and whether paid or left unpaid, expect to see this collection return to at least one of your credit reports in some form and remain there for another three years.
Meet CreditCards.com's reader Q&A expertsDoes a personal finance problem have you worried? Monday through Saturday, CreditCards.com's Q&A experts answer questions from readers. Ask a question, or click on any expert to see their previous answers.
- Q&A: How to achieve a good credit score as a first-time cardholder – Achieving a good credit score is possible even if you are a first-time cardholder. Make sure to never miss a payment, keep a low balance and not apply for another card until your card is a year old ...
- Q&A: How to handle old debt soon to be sent to collections – If sent to collections, an old debt can have legal and credit scoring consequences. Consider the age and amount of the debt before making any decision, and, if you can, find a way to pay it off ...
- Q&A: How credit utilization is calculated in a married couple's scores – For credit scoring purposes we remain single perpetually, but couples can boost each other's credit by adding each other as authorized users to accounts in good standing ...