Recession ended easy credit limit increases
Even good payment history doesn't win any credit favors
Dear Credit Care,
Hello, I am a professor at a major state university, with a corresponding yearly salary. I applied for and received a major bank credit card, but with a credit limit of $500. They refused to increase my limit for a long time, claiming I had "obligations that exceeded my income." I have never had debt on any of my other cards (I have two or three) -- I have always paid them on time and have a very good credit rating from Experian. However, I was just told today by an account executive that they will only increase my limit to $1,000 because I have other credit cards that I could "theoretically" max out and not be able to pay. This is despite the fact that I have never carried debt on my cards, nor have I come anywhere even close to a maximum balance on, for example, my $27,000-limit MasterCard. My question is: Are pretty much all credit card companies determining the credit limits this way now? I find it hard to believe that they refuse to look at customers on a case-by-case basis. Thank you for your time and help. -- Lisa
Those of us who used credit when it was very loose find it difficult to believe that credit is as tight as it is now. Gone are the days when people without adequate proof of income were being approved for mortgages of hundreds of thousands of dollars. What happened in the intervening years was a major financial disaster that caused all creditors to rethink their qualifications for extending credit.
The credit environment is beginning to loosen slowly. However, many creditors are still hesitant to extend credit when they perceive potential for high risk. From your point of view, the potential to max out your available credit on your other credit cards seems ludicrous because you have no history of this, and you know you have no intention of doing so. The creditor, on the other hand, sees the readily available credit that you could tap to overextend yourself and is not willing to take the risk that you will.
In fact, it is remarkable, and most likely due to your excellent credit history, that your limits have not been decreased by your existing card issuers. Many issuers lowered credit limits to lessen their exposure to default even for customers with sterling payment records.
My question for you is why do you want another credit card with a large credit limit if you do not ever charge even close to the maximum credit limit on your current cards and never carry a balance? With $27,000 of credit on only one of your credit cards, you already have access to more credit than the typical credit card user.
If you are opening new credit to improve your credit score, the credit limit on the card should not prevent your from reaching that goal. On the other hand, if you believe you will need access to additional credit for an upcoming large purchase, you might consider a different loan product.
Handle your credit with care!
See related: Help! My bank keeps cutting my credit limit
Meet CreditCards.com's reader Q&A experts
Does a personal finance problem have you worried? Monday through Saturday, CreditCards.com's Q&A experts answer questions from readers. Ask a question, or click on any expert to see their previous answers.
- How to prepare for the next economic downturn – With the current economic expansion aging beyond the normal lifespan, credit counselors advise how to prepare for lean times ...
- Servicemembers Act helps, but soldier, straighten up your debt – The Servicemembers Act limits rates for loans to active-duty military personnel, but controlling debt should be a soldier's first financial duty ...
- If deep in debt, can you negotiate before you're late? – You can try to settle for less than full payment if your credit card bills are current, but it may not work, and don't stop payments to force the issue ...