How to save on a holiday trip to New York City
Enjoy the Big Apple without cutting into your gift shopping budget
Specializes in writing on travel, family and food
The content on this page is accurate as of the posting date. Some of the offers mentioned below may no longer available. Please review our list of best credit cards to find our current offers, or use our CardMatch tool to find cards matched to your needs.
It’s tough to beat New York City when it comes to holiday cheer.
It seems everywhere you turn in the Big Apple there’s another Christmas tree, or another decked out store window and flashing lights (and not just the kind in Times Square) belting out Christmas merriment.
My family recently took a jaunt to the City That Never Sleeps to see the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade live and in person. It was quite the item to check off the bucket list, though unfortunately we had to go the year it was the coldest parade on record. Still, we enjoyed watching the balloons blown up the night before by Central Park, the Radio City Christmas Spectacular and the city’s many ice skating rinks and holiday markets.
Here are my tips for how to save if you’re considering a trip to New York City over the holidays.
My family nearly always flies Southwest Airlines because they tend to have some of the cheapest tickets paired with the best customer service, and because every year we earn the Southwest Companion Pass.
By using our Companion Pass, we are getting the best possible value. We’re flying cheaply (actually, we usually book using points) and we do not have to pay any cash or redeem any points for one ticket, which you can’t beat on pure value.
We booked this trip using Southwest points, costing us about 30,000 points total for four of us to fly, with one using the Companion Pass. We earned the points in a variety of ways – spending on our Southwest Rapid Rewards credit cards, transferring Chase Ultimate Rewards points earned using our Chase Sapphire Reserve and Chase Sapphire Preferred Card and shopping at Southwest’s Rapid Rewards Shopping portal.
A key tip with Southwest when booking with points is to repeatedly check back to see if prices have decreased. If they have decreased, you can “change” your ticket by clicking “Change/Cancel” on the Southwest home page, and it will automatically put the additional points back in your loyalty account. We were able to save about 4,500 points by rebooking our ticket twice when prices lowered.
For our trip, we wanted to stay in Times Square. While it’s not my favorite place due to its chaos and craziness, it was a good location for all the holiday activities we wanted to do. Surprisingly, we were able to book the Crowne Plaza right in the heart of Times Square for 60,000 IHG points per night over Thanksgiving.
One of my other favorite New York hotels is EVEN Hotels Times Square South, which really is not in Times Square despite its name and is health focused from top to bottom. There is also a new Crowne Plaza HY 36 close to the new Hudson Yards development and Madison Square Garden that is uber-cool and has a fun, hip restaurant called TGA. Both are IHG properties and are bookable for 50,000 IHG points per night.
See related: 6 smart-money lessons from holiday movies
There is so much to do in New York at the holidays. A great free activity is to visit the city’s many different holiday markets like the ones at Union Square and Bryant Park. Bryant Park also has an ice skating rink that makes for a wonderful holiday outing, sipping rich hot chocolate from one of the market vendors while watching others skate – or trying it yourself.
You’ll also want to check out Saks Fifth Avenue, which has a magnificent light display set to music. (It plays every evening as soon as it starts to get dark.) Directly across is Rockefeller Center where, of course, you’ll want to see the famous gigantic Christmas tree and maybe take a stroll through FAO Schwarz. Be forewarned – you have to wait in line to shop there!
For sightseeing, I recommend getting the Gray Line Sightseeing Flex Pass, a multi-attraction pass that grants you hop-on, hop-off bus access. This can be a great way to see the city when it’s cold. You can also choose to purchase tickets to between two and 10 attractions and you’ll save up to half off versus buying each ticket directly from the attraction. Plus, the pass lets you skip the long ticket lines.
Lastly, you can’t visit New York City at Christmas without seeing the Radio City Christmas Spectacular, but these tickets are pricey. After asking several locals for tips on getting discounted tickets, we found the best savings at BroadwayBox.com, where we netted half off. We sat on the main level to the left and had a great view.
There are lots of ways to get around New York City, from walking to cabs to Uber to the subway. The best deal depends on the weather, of course – though I like to walk whenever possible – and the number of people traveling with you.
When I visit the city with my family, cabs or Uber end up being cheapest, as we can spread the cost across four people. If I’m alone or it’s just my husband and me, I like to take the subway, where you can buy one-way tickets for as low as $2.75.
Keep in mind transportation counts as a travel expense on cards like Chase Sapphire Preferred and Chase Sapphire Reserve, so we like to use those cards to pay for transportation, enabling us to earn two and three points per dollar.
With a little strategy in hand, you can enjoy a wonderful holiday in New York City and keep more of your money for your Christmas gift list.
- How to save when booking boutique hotels – Boutique hotels offer a personalized and unique experience, but you typically can't book them with your big chain loyalty points. Here's how to use other loyalty and rewards programs and travel cards to book a unique stay ...
- All aboard! These are the best credit cards for cruises – Looking for the best credit cards for cruises? Look no further. From co-branded cruise line-specific cards to flexible travel rewards cards, these are your best options ...
- Poll: Cardholders say they earn most of their rewards from groceries – Rewards card holders say grocery shopping is their most lucrative way of earning points and cash back, according to a new CreditCards.com poll ...