How high of a fee do businesses pay to accept cards?
Ask a question.
Dear Your Business Credit,
I used my Visa to make a payment to my air conditioning company. I was told that my $29 payment was going to cost them $14 so they didn’t want to accept it. Is that true? A charge of $14 on a $29 charge? – Patricia
When I saw your note, my first instinct was that the air-conditioning company was probably exaggerating what it is paying and just wanted you to pay in cash. As Mary Beth Stenzel, owner of credit card payment service Merchant Savers, pointed out in an email, the basic processing fee for a $29 charge would have been about .65 on a basic Visa card. (That would be just under 2.25 percent).
To my surprise, when I consulted with several experts, I found out that a $14 fee – while unlikely – is in the realm of possibility.
"It may be that the air-conditioning company just has the wrong credit card processor,” Jeff White, a financial analyst with FitSmallBusiness.com, said in an email. “Most are very reasonable on rates these days because they're competing against online processing companies with affordable rates. However, there are still some that exist which convince businesses that are not as familiar running credit cards on a consistent basis to sign up with them, and they charge them enormous markup fees.”
As White explained, the processing costs on a credit card are made up of two main fees: (1) The base cost, which is set by Visa or MasterCard, or whoever originated the card being processed, and (2) “markup fees” set by the processor.
“The markup fees have no limit, and are just basically subject to the agreement between the merchant and the processor,” White said.
As a result, the fees the air-conditioning company cited to you could be correct. “If they are, then your air-conditioning company needs to find a new credit card processor,” he said. (Merchants who believe they are overpaying their merchant services provider can find tips on how to shop around for one in “Is it time to negotiate a new merchant account?”)
Then again, White noted, the air-conditioning company might be using high fees as an excuse because it doesn’t want to pay any fees at all.
It’s not clear if the air-conditioning company accepts Visa cards in certain situations or just doesn’t accept them at all. If the company does accept Visa cards but discouraged you in this instance because the purchase was small and the fees would have been disproportionate to the total bill, then it may have been violating Visa’s rules for merchants. “If they accept credit cards, they can only decline payment with credit cards if the transaction is less than $10,” noted Tony DeSanctis, senior director of payments at Cornerstone Advisors, a consulting and research firm.
If you do business with this air-conditioning company on an ongoing basis and know that they do accept Visa in general, you could point this out and conceivably call the Visa phone number on your card to complain. However, it isn’t always easy to find good contractors, and this would probably hurt the merchant, so you may want to keep that in mind.
If you like working with the air-conditioning company for the most part, then you might be better off by offering to pay by check. If you would rather pay electronically, you could point out that if the company sends you an invoice using common accounting software such as QuickBooks or FreshBooks, you can pay them with a free ACH payment directly from your bank account. It’s not easy for small businesses to keep up with all of the options available to them, so they may be happy to know there’s another way to accept electronic payments.
Meet CreditCards.com's reader Q&A experts
Does a personal finance problem have you worried? Monday through Saturday, CreditCards.com's Q&A experts answer questions from readers. Ask a question, or click on any expert to see their previous answers.
- How small businesses can safely store card details – Looking for a small-business solution to storing customer card details? Your merchant processor may offer a service that fits your security and budget needs ...
- Former boss let me use his card, now he cries fraud – If you used a card given by a former boss who is now threatening legal action against you, seek legal advice. You may be able to prove you used the card legitimately ...
- Q&A: How to close a business formed with your ex-spouse – Closing a business formed with an ex-spouse can have legal and tax consequences if not done correctly ...