EMV debit card payment prompts create confusion
Statistics enthusiast focused on data-driven content
As chip-equipped debit cards permeate the market, consumers face new – and potentially confusing – prompts at the register.
Over the past couple of years, credit card holders have grown familiar to the EMV chip credit card payment process: Dip your card, wait, sign, wait for the beep, then retrieve your card.
EMV debit cards transactions start out the same: They are inserted into payment terminals just like chip cards. But as the cards process, some cardholders are asked to select to choose between U.S. Debit or U.S. Visa, or some variation of terms based on the card network and terminal software.
If you’ve used a chip-equipped debit card and been perplexed, here’s the lowdown on the multiplying debit prompt confusion.
The same old choice, asked in many new ways
These prompts are not asking you what type of card it is. They are asking you how you want to process your debit card, and they are asking it of you in a new variety of ways.
When presented with these payment options at a retailer’s register, you’re just being asked whether you want to run the debit card as a debit or credit transaction.
That choice has been offered by many retailers for years, just with different phrases. But now, with chipped debit cards, users may see a greater variety of messages preceding their transactions. Some merchants display a traditional “credit or debit” prompt. Others immediately ask for a PIN, but give cardholders the option to opt out of the PIN. Others have terminals that prompt cardholders with processing options using various terms, based on the card’s network application label.
Prompts vary by retailer
Why all the differences? While big retailers can tweak the payment processing messages customers see, others have to take what they get from their payment processors.
“Smaller retailers get off-the-shelf setups with no scripting personalization. The larger merchants have the ability to customize their user interface,” Jania said. “When you get into local retailers, such as dry cleaners and mom-and-pop shops, they have virtually no ability to change the scripting of the messaging and the way the point-of-sale works.”
Large retailers (think Walmart, Home Depot and Best Buy) buy thousands of point-of-sale terminals to supply retail stores and, as a result, own all the scripting and messages at the point-of-sale. This processing flexibility allows some to offer additional customer conveniences such as electronic receipts instead of paper, or customer loyalty reward redemption options.
“So there is nothing nefarious going on, it’s just based on the capabilities that each merchant has, specifically the larger merchants,” Jania added.
Blame the 'identifiers'
On chip cards, the prompts are made possible by the invention of Application Identifiers, or AIDs. These under-the-hood pieces of information are attached to EMV chips and let payment terminals know what kind of card was dipped and how it should or can be processed. All U.S. debit cards have two: The “Common Debit AID,” which was introduced during the EMV migration to encompass all debit networks, and then a card brand AID.
These two labels produce the messages some consumers are seeing, according to Visa. Cardholders are getting a glimpse into the payment process that was once more hidden.
“You’ve been able to run a credit or debit transaction with a debit card even way back in the mag stripe days,” said Jack Jania, senior vice president of strategic alliances for Gemalto. “However, when chip technology was invented, the way the point-of-sale terminal could recognize a debit card didn’t exist until the Common AID was agreed upon about two years ago. So at that point merchants started changing the consumer prompts at the point-of-sale terminals to reflect that industry update.”
Credit card holders do not see this prompt
The prompts from EMV terminals are solely for debit card holders, and the reason is a 2010 federal law.
The Durbin Amendment, passed as part of the Dodd–Frank Wall Street reform law, created rules that, in addition to setting limits on debit fees, require debit card issuers to support at least two competing networks when processing debit transactions.
“On most EMV chip cards, one option is to route the transaction to the global brand on the card (i.e. Visa debit) or one of the regional debit networks, such as NYCE, STAR or PULSE,” said Randy Vanderhoof, executive director of the Secure Technology Alliance.
The two debit transaction options
While you can click either the credit or debit option using your debit card, your payment will still process as an EMV transaction.
“Both options are compliant with EMV and Durbin rules, but it makes it confusing to consumers,” Vanderhoof said.
- If you want to process your debit card as credit, select the U.S. network option, such as “Visa debit.” Keep in mind that credit-routed debit transactions may take a few business days to process.
- If you want to make a true debit card payment, click the U.S. debit option and then enter your PIN. These transactions are real-time, and the total will be deducted from your checking account balance immediately.
Which is better? It depends. Some debit cards offer rewards or special offers, but only if you process them with a signature over the credit card network.
But under federal laws, debit cards offer slimmer fraud protection than credit cards do. If peace of mind is critical, it’s best to stick with the PIN debit option. “Any transaction that has a PIN will be more secure than a transaction that doesn’t,” Jania said.
Video: PIN vs. signature at checkout
Why is this just being noticed now?
The U.S migration to EMV cards arrived first for credit cards. Banks began mass mailings of debit cards later. As of mid-2017, debit cards with chips finally gained the majority. It has taken time for retailers to get on board with EMV chip debit card processing.
“It takes a while to upgrade point-of-sale systems, it’s not something you can do in months,” Jania explained. “You are just seeing the result of debit now being closer to fully supported by chip.”
Will this experience go away?
This debit card payment prompts confusion will likely fade over time, but probably not right away, so get used to varying retailer experiences.
“Since the bank card issuer and consumer don’t get to decide what the merchant terminal prompts are, I suspect this will be around for a while longer,” Vanderhoof said.
However, as the major card networks abandon signature verifications of transactions, PIN-only prompts will become even more prevalent. Eventually those will go away, too, changing the payment terminal process you are used to once again.
“Moving forward, the trend will be toward a second-factor authentication method that isn’t signature-based,” Jania said. “I think signatures going away will lead to PINs, and PINs will lead to new biometrics. It’s just more convenient.”
- Are mobile card readers safe for small businesses? – Mobile point-of-sale devices equipped with payment technology from companies such as Square and PayPal are convenient for small businesses, but are vulnerable to cybercriminals ...
- How to send, receive money using Zelle – Zelle, the easy-to-use person-to-person payment service now used by more than 100 banks in the U.S., is becoming increasingly popular -- but its simplicity may also make it vulnerable to fraud ...
- How to send, receive money using Venmo – Venmo is a peer-to-peer payment app owned by PayPal. Whether you're a Venmo aficionado or considering opening an account, here's what you need to know, including fees, security, privacy and card use options ...