Variety of rewards cards helps cover bucket list trip costs
A mix of airline, hotel, flexible rewards and cash back cards has its advantages
Travel expert who writes the "Have Cards, Will Travel" column for CreditCards.com
When it comes to your financial portfolio, you’ve likely heard the advice that it’s never wise to “put all your eggs in one basket.” This nugget of wisdom also holds true for credit card points-collecting – especially if you’re planning a big bucket list trip.
In the world of points and miles travel, one credit card rewards program – even the most flexible points-earning bank programs – will never meet every travel need. Diversifying the buckets in which you’re earning reward points is a smart way to ensure you’ll be able to pay for as much of it as possible with the points and miles you’ve earned from your rewards credit cards.
The problem with a single-card earning strategy
In the early years of my credit card rewards points collecting, all of my travel credit cards were from Citi’s American AAdvantage family of rewards cards. The Citi AAdvantage Mastercard was my very first points-earning card – and while it has undergone many revisions in the past 10-plus years, it’s still a card I keep in my arsenal.
The reason I selected this as my first card was simply that I flew American a lot, so it made sense to have a card to help me stockpile points in the AAdvantage program.
The problem, however, was when there wasn’t an award ticket available through American or its oneworld partners – either because of availability or routing – leaving me with no other options other than to purchase the plane ticket I needed.
With only one credit card, all of my points were hostage to the whim of American Airlines.
As I grew older in years and wiser in points, I added the Chase United Explorer card to my wallet. Even though I didn’t fly United a lot, my goal was simply to earn enough points in this account through my credit card spending so I had a backup plan when my American points weren’t able to get me where I needed to go.
Having a single credit card strategy will help you amass great quantities of points in a single program, but if you want to pay for various elements of a trip with rewards instead of dollars – especially a big or expensive trip – you will want to think more broadly.
3 steps to building the perfect credit card portfolio
The perfect combination of credit cards, and the number of cards you’ll want to have in your back pocket is never going to be the same for everyone, yet there are principles you can look to help you make the decision for yourself.
Here are three tips for choosing which combination of points-earning cards works best for your wallet as well as your personal travel aspirations:
1. Mix it up with airline, hotel and bank cards
When you’re thinking about a big trip, you’ll want to broaden your credit card portfolio to include a combination of cards that offer different types of benefits and are able to cover a range of your travel expenses.
Combining the benefits from different types of credit cards allows you to earn the rewards you need to pay for different parts of a trip. If you have, for example, both a co-branded airline card like the United Explorer from Chase and a co-branded hotel card such as the Hilton Honors American Express Ascend Card, through your daily spending you’ll be banking points to cover both your flights and accommodations for your dream trip – often the two largest expenses of any travel.
Earning points in a flexible program such as Chase Ultimate Rewards with a card like the Chase Sapphire Preferred is another way to open up your redemption options to both hotels and airlines without having multiple co-branded cards. However, even flexible points earners should consider mixing up their credit card portfolio to expand the power of their rewards.
I personally love having both the Chase Sapphire Reserve card and the World of Hyatt Credit Card (a flexible card and a co-branded hotel card). Even though I can redeem Ultimate Rewards points for Hyatt stays directly without having the Hyatt specific card, I get maximum benefit when I use the cards together.
Anytime I’m short on World of Hyatt points, I can top up my account with an instant transfer from my Ultimate Rewards stash. When I redeem my points through Hyatt for my free night, I get the added be benefits of free upgrades and late checkout because I have complimentary Hyatt Discoverist elite status as a World of Hyatt card member.
As you expand your portfolio, you’ll find you may keep some cards in your wallet because of their points value, while others you may use simply because of the value of their associated benefits. You may even find yourself adding cards to mirror your growing travel desires as your bucket list evolves.
See related: 5 ways hotel cards add up to big savings
2. Don’t forget cash back
When we focus on travel rewards cards, we often completely focus on points and miles programs, and fail to consider the travel power of the old-yet-reliable cash back credit card.
Cash back cards often come with no annual fee and pay you a small percentage back of all the money you charge. Within this portfolio are travel-specific cash back cards, such as the Barclaycard Arrival Plus World Elite Mastercard. These cards reimburse you the percentage of earned cash back specifically to cover travel-related charges.
The real benefit of having a cash back card in your travel rewards card portfolio is that cash back cards are a great way to cover the costs for parts of your bucket list trip that you won’t be able to pay for with points through a traditional rewards program.
For example, if you’re headed to Tanzania to do the common bucket list trifecta trip of the Serengeti safari, Kilimanjaro climb and Zanzibar recovery weekend, you should easily be able to cover your airfare, transit hotels and Zanzibar hotel nights on points and miles with a little bit of savvy. (I highly recommend using the sign-up bonus from the World of Hyatt Credit Card to book the Park Hyatt Zanzibar in Stone Town for your Kilimanjaro recovery.)
In this case, airfare and a few hotel nights are only two-thirds of your trip. While you can’t use traditional points to pay a safari operator or tour outfitter, cash back rewards can come in very handy.
Simply pay the tour operator with the cash back credit card you’ve been using to earn cash back credits, and these credits will be applied to the charge of the tour. This is also a great strategy for booking cruises, package travel deals or alternative accommodations that points generally won’t cover like Airbnb or Vacasa stays.
3. Think about how you earn (not only how you redeem)
While matching the cards in your wallet to your travel aspirations will help ensure you get the points for the redemptions you want, it’s also smart to consider your spending patterns when picking cards to apply for.
If your primary expenses are weekly trips to the supermarket to feed your family and gas fill-ups to drive your kids to after-school activities, make sure you have cards in your wallet that help you take advantages of grocery store and gas station bonuses (such as the Hilton Ascend card that earns 6x points at supermarkets).
So, how many cards are in my wallet? While I personally have about eight cards in my portfolio – because I take a bucket list trip at least once a year and maintain elite status in two airlines and four hotel programs – the average person would more commonly have somewhere in the range of two to four different rewards cards.
Remember, it isn’t about how fat your wallet is, or if you have the same cards your neighbor swears by. Picking the cards that align with how you spend money and how you want to spend your points is the golden egg that will get you off the couch and on the road for your bucket list adventure.
See related: Video: Master your bucket list with points
- 5 ways to maximize credit card rewards before year end – The last quarter of the year is the time to make sure you're maximizing your rewards cards' annual earning potential. This to-do list will help you take advantage of all the bonuses and perks your cards can offer ...
- When you should pay a flight with cash, when with miles – How do you decide when it is worth spending miles on airfare rather than paying cash? Here are three reasons to pay a flight with cash, three to redeem miles instead, and three scenarios where paying with miles and cash is the way to go ...
- When you should pay a hotel stay with cash, when with points – How do you decide when it is worth spending points on a hotel stay rather than paying cash? Here are three reasons to pay a hotel room with cash, and three scenarios where redeeming points may make more sense ...