Applying for a 2nd credit card: How long do I wait?
The longer your history of good credit, the better the offers will be
Ask a question.
Dear Opening Credits,
I am an 18-year-old student who, while very adept at personal financial management and organization, is new to credit due to age. I have one credit card account open and a total of only five accounts open on my credit report. I have been denied an American Express card despite my credit score because my trade lines haven’t been open for six months yet.
So, my question is, should I wait to apply for another card (or try again with AmEx) after six months or go with something like the Discover it for students that I will be accepted for? Thank you! – Ryan
For a credit issuer to trust that you will be responsible with another credit card, you have to take specific actions with your current batch of accounts for a lengthy period of time. Six months is a start, but a year or more is ideal.
Because you are under the age of 21, federal law prohibits an issuer from offering you a card unless you can prove you have the personal funds to make the payments. Without that, you’ll need a creditworthy person to co-sign.
However, as long as you meet the income and credit rating requirements, you should be able to get a card on your own. Here’s why that’s a smart idea, and how you can get a second credit card to round out your credit portfolio.
Having another credit card will increase your credit scores. Use the cards the right way and twice the amount of positive information will be on your credit reports. With two credit cards as well as your other accounts (student loans and car financing perhaps?), there will be sufficient data for FICO and VantageScore, the most common credit scoring companies, to analyze.
Credit scores are designed to predict lending risk, so how you’ve dealt with various loans and lines of credit in the past is an indicator of how you will treat them in the future.
Many students have jobs, so if you are working, list thatt on the credit card application. Then take American Express’ advice. Delay applying until you have at least six months of activity with your current credit card on your reports.
While you can try for the Discover it chrome for students card, it requires a “fair” credit rating. That means a credit score in the mid-600s or above (FICOs and VantageScores start at 300 and go up to 850). American Express products, however, tend to demand higher-than-average scores.
Now here are my recommendations:
1. Charge small, pay in full on time, repeat
This should be easy for you because of your excellent money management skills! For the card you have, keep your spending as far below the credit limit as you can, but do use the card regularly.
Identify a relatively small expense and charge it to your card once per month. By doing this, you’ll never appear to be overextended, thus protecting your credit score from damage.
Pay the balance off in full by the due date.
Maintain this pattern month after month to populate your credit reports with the kind of activity that shows you really are financially capable.
Regarding your other accounts, which I presume are loans, just pay them on time, and if you can, send more than is required to drive the debt down faster. The less you owe the better it is for your credit rating.
If you face a financial emergency in which you have to rack up a large charge, don’t wait for the bill to come. Write a check for it as soon after the purchase as you can.
2. After six months, check your credit reports and scores
It appears you’ve already seen your credit reports, but after six months, check them again.
Make sure only correct information is listed, and if you see something wrong, dispute it with the reporting agency. You don’t want to get rejected for credit due to a mistake.
3. Apply for the card that best suits you and your scores – or wait
This is where you have a choice.
If you have a sound and independent income and follow the charging plan I described, in six months you should qualify for a variety of credit cards. An easy way to search for one within reach is the CreditCards.com CardMatch program that makes card suggestions based on your credit.
If no card is appealing, continue on as before until you’ve reached the year mark. Pull your scores again. Your scores should be higher, and your options more diverse.
Finally, only pursue the credit product that you’re eligible for and truly want. An overabundance of inquiries will hurt your credit scores. When you’re in the market for any kind of credit product, you’ll want to make sure those numbers are as high as possible.
Meet CreditCards.com's reader Q&A experts
Does a personal finance problem have you worried? Monday through Saturday, CreditCards.com's Q&A experts answer questions from readers. Ask a question, or click on any expert to see their previous answers.
- Card way over the limit? Here's a debt payoff plan – It's rare to go over your credit limit, but when that happens, you need a plan to pay off your debt fast. Get a side gig, sell items, increase your income to erase your card debt to zero ...
- Don't wait until due date to pay first card bill – To make sure your scores are not affected by any charged amount, large or small, is to pay what you’ve charged immediately ...
- Q&A: Can I protect my credit score if I can't pay card's full balance? – Until you are able to regain control of your debt, take these steps to protect your credit score ...