Debt Management

4 last-ditch, high-cost loans to avoid


Overspend on the holidays? A short-term loan may seem like manna from heaven, but some loans may leave you in worse shape than before

The content on this page is accurate as of the posting date; however, some of our partner offers may have expired. Please review our list of best credit cards, or use our CardMatch™ tool to find cards matched to your needs.

If you’re coming out of a holiday daze to find that it has left you severely short on cash, a short-term loan to tide you over for a  little while may seem like manna from heaven. However, you could end this year in worse shape than you started as some high-cost, short-term loans are bad deals all year around.

There’s no shortage of lenders advertising loan products to help you get over the high-holiday-bill blues by allowing you to continue to borrow. For example,, an online marketplace for payday lenders, announced its “New Year Resolution Loan Finder,” while another,, suggests that a short-term loan could help you get your finances in order in 2013.

But while a short-term loan can get you out of a bad fix, certain types of loans can leave you in a bigger hole.

4 high-cost desperation loans to avoid

Loans to avoid
1. At the top of the list of loans to steer clear of are payday loans, in which you get an advance on your next paycheck and the lender gets his money back — along with fees and interest — when your paycheck arrives.

Payday loans, however, are notorious for their extraordinarily high interest rates.  According to the Center for Responsible Lending (CRL), the average payday loan charges between a 391 percent and 521 percent interest rate.  Not only that, but once the payday lender is paid, consumers typically don’t have enough money left over to pay other bills, so they take out another loan or refinance or rollover the current payday loan — and accrue even more fees and interest.

“People’s situations can spiral downward very quickly,” says Deanna Booker, a spokeswoman for Consumer Credit Counseling Services of Maryland and Delaware. “Payday loans are a debt trap because you always need another one.” In fact, the CRL found that the average payday loan borrower takes out nine loans per year.

While payday lenders used to be primarily storefront shops, they are increasingly moving online, says Tom Feltner, director of financial services for the Consumer Federation of America (CFA). Not only are payday lenders offering virtual loans, but some sites claim to take your information, sift through multiple payday lenders and find the “best loan” for you. However, in many cases, “what they’re really doing is selling your information to see which payday lender is going to pay the most to get your business,” Feltner adds.

2. Another loan to avoid is the car title loan, which is similar in structure to payday loans, but throws in an additional requirement of borrowers: In return for a short-term loan, you must turn over the title of your car so the lender can take possession of it if you don’t pay up on time. The interest rates charged on car title loans tend to be 20 to 30 times more than the typical rates charged by credit card issuers, according to the CRL. Since most people can’t pay the entire loan back when it’s due, the average car title borrower renews the loan eight times, the CRL found.

3. With tax time comes tax refunds, and if you’re in a hurry to pay off bills, it’s easy to fall for an offer to expedite that refund. In years past, tax preparation firms were eager to oblige you with high-fee refund anticipation loans. They’d loan you the amount you expected on your tax return, minus a hefty fee that translated into an annualized interest rate of 1,000 percent or more. After seeing large-scale abuse, the Internal Revenue Service stopped providing information to lenders that facilitated the loans. No data, plus bad publicity, made banks rethink the product, and 2012 was the last year they were available from federally regulated banks. In their place, however, new come-ons for “refund anticipation checks” have sprung up. They are deposit products, not loans, but guess what they share with their closely named predecessor? You got it. Big fees. Don’t fall for them. With quick, electronic deposits available from Uncle Sam, “refund anticipation” has become a short-lived malady anyway.

People’s situations can spiral downward very quickly. Payday loans are a debt trap because you always need another one.

— Deanna Booker
Consumer Credit Counseling Services
of Maryland and Delaware

4. Some big banks and credit unions are offering short-term loans with terms that are comparable to payday loans, says Kathleen Day, a spokeswoman for the CRL. In many cases, the bank will deposit the money into your checking account and then automatically deduct the loan amount plus fees when you receive your paycheck. According to the Center for Responsible Lending, the average APR on such loans is 365 percent. Earlier this month, Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) sent a letter to Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Chairman Martin Gruenberg and Comptroller of the Currency Thomas J. Curry, asking for action to stop banks from these payday lending practices. According to Blumenthal’s letter, the average borrowers of these short-term bank loans find themselves renewing the loan at least 16 times over a year’s time.

Signs of a bad loan
If you have to borrow money, make sure the loan is one that you will realistically be able to repay, says Todd Mark, vice president of education for Consumer Credit Counseling Services of Greater Dallas. In most cases, the two weeks until your next paycheck is not enough time.

You want to avoid:

  • Lenders who do not check your credit and income to make sure you can actually afford the loan.
  • Lenders who automatically deduct funds from your checking account.
  • Loans that have a high double digit or three digit annual percent rate. (Note that these lenders will typically not advertise their APRs.)

The good news is there are better avenues to explore.

In an absolute emergency, “people would be better off using a credit card,” says Day. But exercise discipline and avoid adding new charges so you can pay the bill off within a year, Day adds.

You may also be able to find a good short-term loan product from a bank, many of which have added affordable new products that carve into the business of payday lenders without gouging consumers. A 2011 survey conducted by the FDIC found that 20 percent of households that took out payday loans did so because they didn’t think they could get small-dollar loans from a bank. Yet, the same survey found that eight out of 10 banks offered personal loans under $2,500 and many of those loans had repayment terms of 90 days or more with APRs of 36 percent or less.

If you’re considering taking out a loan to make a payment on another loan, talk to your creditor and explain that you’re experiencing a temporary cash crunch and ask for an extension on the due date rather than picking up a new debt, suggests Booker.

See related:Big banks get into the payday loan business

Editorial Disclaimer

The editorial content on this page is based solely on the objective assessment of our writers and is not driven by advertising dollars. It has not been provided or commissioned by the credit card issuers. However, we may receive compensation when you click on links to products from our partners.

What’s up next?

In Debt Management

Know the 8 emotional spending triggers

Budget plans usually start with a month or so of data gathering, but that’s the easy part. Evaluating why you spend what you do is the trick

See more stories
Credit Card Rate Report
Cash Back

Questions or comments?

Contact us

Editorial corrections policies

Learn more