Which credit cards should your small business accept?
Consumer choice is key but watch out for fees
Your Business Credit
Elaine Pofeldt is a journalist whose articles on entrepreneurship and careers have appeared in Fortune, Working Mother, Money and many other publications. She is a former senior editor at Fortune Small Business magazine and an entrepreneur herself, as co-founder of 200kfreelancer.com, a website for independent professionals. She writes "Your Business Credit," a weekly column about small business and credit, for CreditCards.com.
Ask Elaine a question
or read her prior answers in the 'Your Business Credit' archive
Dear Your Business Credit,
I am planning to open a new restaurant. I've noticed
that some businesses accept a variety of credit cards, while others will accept
just one or two, usually Visa and MasterCard. Does it cost a lot more to accept
a variety of cards than it does if you limit customers to just one or two? -- Steve
It's smart to carefully think through decisions like this
as you launch your restaurant.
Many of us have found ourselves in situations where
we forgot to make an ATM withdrawal, had only one credit card in our wallet and
discovered that a store or restaurant we planned to patronize did not accept that
card. The only choice in those situations, if there's no ATM nearby, is to go
Offering a full range of credit cards will prevent
that from happening to customers at your restaurant. Generally speaking, the
more options for payment you offer your clientele, the easier it will be to
make sales, says Tim Peter, a
consultant in Long Valley, N.J., who helps customers in the retail, hospitality
and restaurant industries drive sales.
"If they want to use American Express because they
want the rewards points, you'll have a better chance of making a sale," says
Peter, who previously ran 27 websites for the hotel chain Wyndham Worldwide.
That said, there are fees to consider. Typically,
when you open a merchant account that enables you to accept credit cards,
you'll have the option of accepting a full range of cards through that account,
says Seth Broman, vice president of
business development at Merchant Cash and Capital in New York City, which
provides working capital to small businesses. There are different types of merchant account fees. Usually, you'll pay a
setup fee, as well as a monthly account fee and, in some cases, an annual fee.
Those fees don't increase if, say,
you opt to offer three types of cards instead of two. "For the most part, when
you apply to open a merchant services account, you'll automatically be able to
process Visa, MasterCard and, mostly, Discover -- and to initiate a new American Express account," Broman says. "It's just one application you're going
to be submitting."
Where the costs of accepting different cards varies
is on transaction fees and per-item fees. Merchant Account Guide can help
you compare the costs of various merchant accounts.
Typically, merchants pay card processors 1.5 percent
to 3 percent of each credit card transaction, according to Consumer Action, a
consumer advocacy group. Besides these "interchange fees," you may also have to
pay a per item fee to the processor. Currently, the range of such fees listed
on MerchantAccountGuide.com is 14 cents to 25 cents per transaction. If you also want to accept debit cards -- which is a good idea given how widely
they are used -- interchange fees are capped at 21 cents, plus .05 percent of
the transaction value and a one-cent fraud-prevention adjustment.
The type of cards your customers use may raise your
fees. For instance, you might get charged a higher fee if a customer uses a
premium card or one that offers rewards points, notes Peter. Once you agree to
accept a particular type of card, such as a Visa card, you have to accept all
kinds of Visa cards. You can't cherry-pick the ones with the lowest fees,
according to Peter.
American Express cards
work differently from MasterCard and Visa. AmEx offers both
a monthly flat-fee plan -- where you can opt to pay a set fee instead of a
percentage of each transaction -- as well as a plan where you pay a percentage
of each transaction. In the latter case, the percentage depends on your type of
business. If you run a full-service restaurant with annual revenues up to $5
million, for example, you could pay fees as low as 2.9 percent of each
transaction, plus 5 cents on top of that. The top fee for a full-service
restaurant is 3.5 percent, plus an extra 5 cents per transaction.
Generally speaking, says Peter, "The fees on
American Express are higher." This is because American Express cards are viewed
as premium cards, offered to high-end consumers, he explains. "If you're a
small retailer operating on very low margins, over the course of a year, the
cost could really add up," he says.
As of Jan. 27 it is possible in many states
for merchants to explicitly pass along swipe fees to customers. However, doing so could discourage customers from
coming to your restaurant. If you do opt to pass along fees, you must post a
sign at the entrance and the checkout terminal, and include a notice on customers' receipts. And you can't add a surcharge that is greater than what
you actually pay for swiping the cards.
See related: Merchant debit card swipe fees rise for small dollar purchases, Credit card surcharges? No way, poll says, Why a phantom credit card surcharge makes sense to retailers
Elaine Pofeldt is a journalist who specializes in entrepreneurship and careers, contributing to publications such as Fortune, Money, Working Mother and many others. She is a former senior editor at Fortune Small Business magazine and an entrepreneur herself, as co-founder of 200kfreelancer.com, a website for independent professionals.
Elaine answers a question about small business and credit from a CreditCards.com reader each week.
Send your question to Your Business Credit.
Published: February 4, 2013
Three most recent Merchant accounts stories:
- 3 ways to minimize holiday returns without losing customers – A spate of post-holiday returns can make a real dent in your profits. There are ways for even small businesses to minimize returns without offending customers used to generous policies from retail giants
- New business financing sources to try when the bank says no – With bank loans still eluding many small businesses years after the global financial crisis, new online services are sniffing out opportunity to fill the gap in the credit marketplace ...
- Savvy ways to finance holiday inventory – Retailers need to avoid financing inventory they are not sure they can sell — which can leave them stuck paying interest on goods they'll have to mark down in January. That's especially true for those who rely on costly credit card financing ...