Poll: Paper bank statements remain popular
54 percent still get paper, but younger consumers have gone digital
By Susan Ladika | Published: June 22, 2016
Rob Goebel, Lana Kotioukova/CreditCards.com
Rob Goebel, Lana Kotioukova/CreditCards.com
When it comes to financial statements, paper's still popular.
Even in an increasingly digital world, even after years of banks pushing consumers toward e-statements with rewards or fees, more than half of consumers continue to have paper financial statements delivered by mail, says a new CreditCards.com national poll of 1,000 U.S. adults.
Among our findings:
- Fifty-four percent of American adults say they get a credit card or checking account paper statement by mail.
- Age is a huge factor in whether people prefer paper or digital financial statements. Among young millennials age 18-25, for example, just 6 percent say they get monthly credit card statement by mail. The oldest consumers, 71 and older, are six times more likely to get paper: 36 percent say they get paper credit card statements. The numbers are similar for checking and debit card accounts.
- For those who prefer paper, loyalty is fierce. Nearly half (46 percent) say they would not switch even if they were charged extra for mailed statements. A $5 account credit and and a 10 percent discount coupon wouldn't be enough inducement for most, either (see chart). Only a $50 account credit would be enough to tip a bare majority (52 percent) into switching.
- For many, it's not an either-or choice: They get both. The poll found 55 percent of those who receive their checking and debit card account statements online also receive paper copies, while 44 percent of those who receive credit card statements electronically also get paper statements.
|Do you get a monthly credit card statement through the mail? Or review statements online?
|Paper statements through the mail?
|Review statements online?
|Don’t get monthly statement||
|Don't have a credit card||
Source: CreditCards.com telephone survey of 1,000 U.S. adults. Survey conducted June 2-5, 2016 by Princeton Survey Research Associates International. Margin of error, +/- 3.7 percentage points
Go online, say banks
The federal E-Sign Act, enacted in 2000, allows financial institutions to send electronic statements, if a consumer makes that choice. If it were up to the banks, we'd all be getting e-statements and sending e-payments. They're substantially less expensive.
A 2015 study by the U.S. Postal Service examined the costs that an undisclosed, large utility company spent sending and processing payments by paper versus electronically. The utility spent 6 cents to send and process a consumer's payment electronically. To send the bill by paper and get a paper check back cost nine times more – 53 cents.
Some financial institutions have responded to the higher cost by charging consumers for paper statements. At two major banks, Regions Bank and U.S. Bank, consumers are charged $2 a month in service fees for paper statements. Commerce Bank, a large Midwestern bank, charges $3 per statement, while TD Bank charges $1 per statement. Bank Financial, based in the Chicago area, charges customers $3 a month for paper statements; it waives the fee for customers 65 and older.
Other financial institutions chose to offer carrots rather than wield sticks. Many community banks and credit unions, for example, offer rewards checking accounts, which can yield rates as high as 3 percent or 4 percent, but customers typically must agree to receive electronic statements, as well as use their debit cards a certain number of times each month and receive direct deposits.
Why people like paper statements
Those with a preference for paper say:
- They like to keep paper for their records (80 percent).
- They like to pay bills by check, and mailed statements provide the bill and the envelope (50 percent).
- The paper serves as a reminder the bill has to be paid (74 percent).
- They're just used to paper (67 percent).
Why people like e-statements
Those who use digital statements base their preference on:
- They can access them anywhere (82 percent).
- It's environmentally friendly to save paper (65 percent).
- You can pay bills faster (86 precent).
- They're just used to being online (76 percent).
Online access concerns
The practice of reviewing statements online is a major concern for the National Consumer Law Center (NCLC), which earlier this year did a study on paper statements.
“Electronic statements might seem cool and environmentally friendly, and paper statements may seem old-fashioned, but paper is just easier to review,” says Chi Chi Wu, an attorney who co-wrote the NCLC report.
By not reviewing their credit card statements, cardholders miss out on important information such as the card’s interest rate and minimum payment information, and they won’t notice if fraudulent transactions occur.
Consumers who overlook online notifications and miss a payment concern Ben Rogers, managing director of research for the Filene Research Institute, a think-tank for the credit union industry. “It can do a lot of things pretty quickly to your credit,” including late fees and higher interest rates.
|What would it take to get you to switch from paper to e-statements?
|A $5 credit to your account?
|A $50 credit to your account?
|A coupon for a 10% off discount at your favorite store?||
|Being required to pay extra for paper statements?||
Source: CreditCards.com telephone survey of 1,000 U.S. adults. This question was asked of the 610 who say they get at least one paper credit card or checking statement. Survey conducted June 2-5, 2016 by Princeton Survey Research Associates International. Margin of error, +/- 4.7 percentage points
Reviewing matters most
Bruce McClary, spokesman for the National Foundation for Credit Counseling, says the format of statements isn't as important as looking at them. “Whichever one you pay the most attention to is the one you should get,” he says.
Regardless of which delivery method you choose, “It’s so very important people keep an eye on their monthly statements. You can see what happens and react in real time.”
The 2016 CreditCards.com financial statements survey was conducted by Princeton Survey Research Associates International via telephone interviews with a nationally representative sample of 1,000 adults living in the continental United States from June 2-5, 2016. Statistical results are weighted to correct known demographic discrepancies. The margin of sampling error for the complete set of weighted data is plus or minus 3.7 percentage points.
- Rejection of credit card applications rises, New York Fed survey shows – Consumers got turned down for cards at highest rate since 2015, New York Fed survey says ...
- The history of credit cards – From charge plates to Apple Pay, here's a look back at the many iterations of the credit card over the past 150 years ...
- Fed: Card balances jump $7.3 billion in May – Credit card balances continued their sprint toward an all-time high in May, according to the Federal Reserve ...