Unscrupulous lenders bend collections rules
How to defend yourself against collectors when the debt isn't yours
To Her Credit
Dear To Her Credit,
An ex-roommate opened a credit card account in her name and put my name as an additional user on the account without my knowledge or consent. She did not sign my name or give any other information like my Social Security number. She ran up over $1,000 in charges on the account and defaulted. I did not even know the account existed until collection efforts began. The bank is trying to get me to pay the bill -- even though the collections agency acknowledged that I'm not listed as a jointly responsible party or primary debtor on the account. My Social Security number is not associated with the account -- which TransUnion has confirmed.
I filed a police report and submitted it to both the bank and the collection agency. Is there anything else I should do? TransUnion deleted the delinquent account from my credit report in February 2008. Could it "re-appear" on my credit report? Any help you can provide will be most appreciated. -- Karon
This happens more often than you would think. It's so easy to add someone to a card as an authorized user -- you don't need their signature, financial information, or knowledge. If you can spell someone's name, you can add them to your card.
You have no financial responsibility for this account, and the bank knows it. That doesn't stop unscrupulous companies from trying to collect, however.
You are experiencing debt collection violations. According to Georg Finder, Independent Credit Evaluator, the bank is violating the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, a federal law since 1977. The bank knows you are not responsible for the bill. Because the collections agency and TransUnion agree you are not responsible for this debt, Finder says, "The lack of responsibility has been acknowledged by more than one entity, so that one collector pursuing it is in violation of the law."
You're on the right track for fixing this problem. Filing a police report was the right thing to do. Adding you as a user is not a crime, but identity theft is. You don't know what else she has done with your name and information, so having a report on record is a good precaution.
Notifying the credit bureaus was also smart. You need to do a few more things to protect yourself:
- Check your credit report and the interest rates on any other credit cards you own. "If they put it in her credit report and she has other credit cards, they will see that and her interest rates will rise," says Finder. Your ex-roommate's shenanigans can make the interest rates on all your cards go up!
- If your credit is affected, get legal help. Finder says you should be able to get a lawyer who will take your case "on spec," meaning you don't have to pay an upfront fee. You may be entitled to $1,000 in statutory damages per federal law, plus you are entitled to additional damages if this has affected your credit. (You can find a lawyer through your county bar association.)
- Make the bank stop harassing you. The creditor may have given up collecting from your ex-roommate, but he's looking for anyone with a deep pocket -- whether he violates the law or not. "Overwhelmingly, they know the law, but they're ignoring it," says Finder. To stop the harassment, you can't just meekly say, "Go away." Send a letter to the collector or account holder saying why this is a harassing and improper activity, and state that if they continue to report this to the credit bureaus, you will protect your legal rights. Specifically tell them to "cease and desist."
- Rarely, a company will keep trying to collect even after being told to stop. If they call you again, keep a diary of calls made to establish a willful pattern of violation. If they put your information in a credit report, save a record. Victims of this kind of harassment are entitled to up to $1,000 per violation. Finder says, "It gets even more exciting if there is provable credit damage." Finder tells about an extreme case that went to a jury trial in Los Angeles, where the plaintiff was awarded $290,000 for what he went through.
There's no reason for you to be harassed for someone else's bills. Stand up for yourself, and get help if you need it! Good luck!
Meet CreditCards.com's reader Q&A expertsVexed by a personal finance problem? CreditCards.com's Q&A experts answer questions from readers every weekday. Ask a question, or click on any expert to see their previous answers.
Published: August 1, 2008
- Lost job? Budget, don't stop card payments – Prepare a bare-bones budget and cut all nonessential spending before you stop paying on cards ...
- For tax purposes, card statements aren't detailed receipts – Don't rely on your card statement if you want a precise record of spending; keep that original paper receipt ...
- Card owner's dementia, death make it hard to prove theft – The neighbor of a man with dementia went to town with his card. After his death, it's hard to distinguish theft from generosity ...