How debt management plans impact credit scores
Erica Sandberg is a prominent personal finance authority and author of "Expecting Money: The Essential Financial Plan for New and Growing Families." She writes "Opening Credits," a weekly reader Q&A column about issues for people who are new to credit, for CreditCards.com.
Ask a question.
'Opening Credits' stories
Dear Opening Credits,
I have decided to look
for a debt management plan (DMP) to enroll in. The decision was based on the fact
that, although my credit score is good currently (I've just purchased my first
home), it doesn't look like I've made a dent in my debts (roughly $40,000).
I had been paying
slightly more than the minimum payments until the past year. I have always made
my payments and never used to pay my bills late nor been delinquent until recently.
Now with the price of gas and daily living expenses continuing to increase, I
find it harder and harder because of living from paycheck to paycheck.
I'm hopeful this plan
will get me out from under this before I retire. Right now, I have a mortgage
and HOA fees, which I pay on time. How severely do you think my credit score
will be impacted if I use a debt management program? Most of the debt
management programs I've researched say they will close all my credit cards (but
I might be able to keep one card for emergencies). I have always heard not to close credit cards
because it would bring down your credit rating. The balances on the cards that
will be enrolled in the program are near maxed out already, so I cannot imagine
the impact being much more negative. I have an 11-year-old car that will probably
need to be replaced sooner or later. What would the possibility be of buying a
car while I was on the program? -- Kathy
You were overextended
before you bought your home and you're really overextended now.
Living within your means
is a matter of simple math. As an employed person, you have a fixed amount of
money coming in every month from your job. Then you make choices of where and
how you're going to spend your earnings. Each purchase you make eats into the
available cash, leaving you less for the other things you may want or need.
If you manage your
finances well, you don't come up short at the end of the month or pay period.
But if you mismanage them, you spend more than you make and get into debt.
Which is, I'm afraid, what you've been doing.
programs that credit counseling organizations offer can be a great way for
people to climb out of the hole they have gotten themselves into. I'm glad
you're exploring them. But more than that, these agencies can help you with the
bigger problem, which is you living on the economic edge. That's a precarious
and frightening place to be.
During your appointment,
the counselor will thoroughly review your entire financial picture.
She will review your assets, income, expenses and debts, then come up with some
options for relief based on your short, mid, and long-term goals. If the debt
management plan (DMP) makes sense for you, she'll suggest it as a method for
you to satisfy your creditors within three to five years. Many creditors who
work with these agencies decrease or even eliminate interest, so more of your
payment will go toward the principal.
However, before your
counselor can even suggest the DMP, the two of you have to come together to
ensure that you have enough money to make the payments comfortably. That may
require budgeting. Most clients have to cut out some expenses or increase their
income to meet the terms. This is a very powerful and valuable process. It
sheds light on where you've been overdoing it. And when you know that, you can
As far as how the DMP affects a credit score, well, it doesn't. Some creditors might notify the
credit bureaus that you're paying through a third-party service, but that
notice is not factored into a FICO score calculation. It's true that you would
have to close the cards included on the plan. However, the negative impact that
should have is slight, and would be overridden by the positive effect of you
steadily deleting the balances, which is much more important to a score.
Borrowing for a new
vehicle while you're on a DMP is generally frowned upon. When you enroll in a
DMP, the credit counseling agency makes a promise to your current creditors
that you will not get into any more debt. So look for alternatives. If the
maintenance on the car you're driving is too expensive, making a different one
necessary, save up as much as you can and buy a used, super-basic model. If you
must take out a car loan, be sure to bring this up with your counselor, so the payment can be worked into your proposed budget.
Oh, and how will the bank
or car finance company perceive a DMP notation? That depends. Some will
consider it good, others bad and still others will have no opinion at all.
See related: The pros and cons of debt management plans, In a debt management plan? No new credit for you
Erica Sandberg is a nationally renowned personal finance authority. She’s host of several financial web shows, and a frequent guest for media outlets such as Fox, Forbes, Nightly Business Report and NPR. Erica previously was affiliated with Consumer Credit Counseling Service and was KRON-TV’s on-air credit expert. Her book, "Expecting Money: The Essential Financial Plan for New and Growing Families," was published in 2008 by Kaplan Press.
Send your question to Erica.
Published: August 1, 2012
Three most recent Opening Credits stories: