Debt collectors' use of social media raises concerns
Government, consumer groups ponder need for guidelines
new technologies and social media transforming
the way debt collectors reach out to debtors, consumer groups, collection
agencies and government officials are questioning whether new guidelines are
needed to help collectors do their jobs, while protecting consumers from overzealous collection practices.
a relatively new phenomenon for debt collectors to be using social media to try
to locate and communicate with consumers," says Suzanne Martindale, staff
attorney for Consumers Union. So new, in fact, that many in the industry are
puzzled about what collectors can legally do with social media, Martindale
says. "We have concerns about debt collectors using social networking in part
because the law really is unclear and there's such a risk of invading people's
privacy," she says.
Since social media sites have grown in popularity,
reports have surfaced of debt collectors not only scouring Facebook and other
sites to locate elusive debtors, but in some instances, creating fake user
names and friending people in order to get information about a debtor's
In response to such concerns, the Federal Trade
Commission hosted a workshop in April, bringing together government, the
collections industry and consumer groups to discuss the impact of new
technologies on the collections process. "The specific issues under consideration at this
workshop had to do with how mobile telephones, e-mail, social media,
information gathering tools and software platforms affect collectors'
compliance with the law," says Betsy Lordan, a spokeswoman for the FTC.
A new frontier
denies reports that the FTC had decided to establish a committee to
deal specifically with collectors' use of social media, but says the agency is
still reading through public comments collected during the workshop, as well as
the transcripts of workshop participants.
FTC receives more complaints about the debt collection industry than any other
specific industry," Lordan says. There
were 140,036 complaints about third-party debt collectors and in-house
collectors in 2010, though not all about social media, "so the FTC certainly is
concerned about the level of complaints that debt collectors generate," Lordan
We don't need new
regulations. We need to enforce the ones we've got.
CEO, Collections Marketing Center
no further action addressing the issue of social media has been announced at
this time, Martindale says the workshop was a good first step. However,
Consumers Union and other consumer groups would like to see the FTC come up
with a set of guidelines that would deal specifically with social media,
telling collectors what they can and cannot do, Martindale says.
"Maybe there is a way to use social media
responsibly, but until we get some guidance about what that looks like, it's
going to be tricky," she says.
some collections industry executives argue that current debt collection
guidelines can be applied to social media. The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) governs the debt collection industry,
making provisions designed to prevent collectors from harassing debtors. For
example, according to the law, debt collectors cannot lie or misrepresent
themselves when they collect a debt. That would make it illegal for a collector
to create a false profile and mislead a user on Facebook, points out Vytas
Kisielius, chief executive officer of Collections Marketing Center Inc., a
Wilmington, Del.-based collections company.
FDCPA also makes it illegal to contact a debtor via postcard, which could
infringe upon the debtor's privacy, or discuss a debt with anyone other than
the debtor. Applying that law to social media would make it illegal to post a
message on a Facebook user's wall, Kisielius says. "We don't need new
regulations. We need to enforce the ones we've got," he adds.
there's nothing in the law that would and should prevent debt collectors from
using social media sites to gather information, Kisielius says. Debtors who
want to keep certain information from debt collectors shouldn't post it online,
he says. "I don't understand why -- if you're willing to put information about
yourself on a billboard -- that information can't be publicly available to
folks that want to know about you," he says.
Others in the debt collection industry have asked the FTC to provide more guidance about how debt collectors can make the most of new technology such as social media. In a comment to the FTC, ACA International, an association of credit card collection professionals, writes that "uncollected consumer debt threatens the economy" and points to a 2008 study by PriceWaterhouseCoopers that found that collection agencies returned $40.4 billion to creditors in 2007. Yet, technology has changed the way consumers communicate, and the FDCPA does not reflect that, the association adds.
In another comment submitted to the FTC, Norfolk, Va.-based debt collection company Portfolio Recovery Associates points out that consumers also benefit from the use of new technolgoies to collect debt. "Resolutions of our accounts are least expensive to customers when we are able to engage them in conversation quickly and with the fewest impediments," writes Donald W. Redmond, vice president of government relations for the company. "Attempts to constrain communication between debt collectors and their customers increase the frequency of debt collection litigation, which is both costly and uncomfortable for consumers."
have varying opinions on the matter, as shown by the public comments collected
by the FTC.
like Kelly Dixon of Wisconsin are vehemently opposed to collectors using social
media. "If I choose to open an account on LinkedIn in order build a good base
of networking contacts, or relax on my own time and wonder [sic] through
Facebook to catch up with old friends, then I should not have to worry about my
contact list being assaulted by the credit police," Dixon wrote.
say collectors must be able to adapt their practices to the current times. "As
our society moves to the mobile environment and many individuals no longer have
land lines; it is important to find ways to communicate with these
individuals," wrote John Gies of Colorado.
now, consumers must do what they can to protect themselves by watching what
information they put on social media sites and using the sites' privacy
settings to keep strangers from accessing their information, says Martindale.
If they believe their privacy rights have been violated, consumers can instruct
the collector, in writing, to stop contacting them, and they can report it to
the FTC, the Better Business Bureau, their state's attorney general or the
newly established Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
The FTC will continue to monitor complaints closely and
decide if further action is warranted, Lordan says. "The goal is to evaluate the
benefits, as well as potential problems, of debt collectors using social media
and the other technologies discussed to communicate with consumers."
See related: Watch what you post! Debt collectors turn to social media
, Know your rights: the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act
Published: August 2, 2011
Three most recent Legal, regulatory, privacy issues stories: