Small banks, credit unions keep debit rewards programs alive
By Tony Mecia | Published: July 9, 2014
Three years after big banks started pulling the plug on debit card rewards programs, many small banks and credit unions are finding surprising success in offering similar rewards to their customers.
The big guys' departure, prompted by federal regulation limiting their merchant fees, left room for the banking small fry, who see the obvious: Debit cards are in everyone's pockets, accounting for nearly 50 percent more noncash transactions than credit cards. And who doesn't like to earn rewards for spending money?
"There is some renewed interest in this," says Ron Shevlin, senior analyst with research and advisory firm Aite Group. "It is surprising, because a lot of people didn't forecast that there would be this shift back to credit that would prompt the need for more competitive debit reward programs."
Small banks and credit unions offering rewards for debit say it fits well with their customer-focused philosophy. While the rewards are typically meager compared to those that come with credit cards, smaller financial institutions are maintaining or expanding their reward programs.
Shevlin's analysis of Aite Group research says most credit unions and small banks view debit as their biggest chance for growth. Among those with a debit card rewards program in place, 60 percent said the program helped drive usage.
"They're recognizing they have to do something to protect that revenue stream, and make debit cards competitive to the credit side," he says.
Debit is king
Between 2000 and 2011, the use of debit cards took off, growing from 8.3 billion transactions in 2000 to more than five times that number by 2011. In 2004, the number of debit card payments eclipsed credit card payments, and debit has been the favored form of payment ever since.
It is surprising, because a lot of people didn't forecast that there would be this shift back to credit that would prompt the need for more competitive debit reward programs.
The 2007-2008 recession contributed to the growth. When it hit, consumers came to see debit cards as a financially sensible way to live within their means.
While debit cards remain popular, their surge has been slowed by industry changes. In 2010, the landmark Dodd-Frank financial reform legislation included a provision known as the Durbin Amendment, a measure favored by retailers because it directed the Federal Reserve to cap the fees that big banks charged merchants for debit card transactions. The regulations, which took effect in 2011, wound up capping large banks' debit card transaction fees at half their former level.
The rules applied only to financial institutions with assets of more than $10 billion.
With debit cards becoming less profitable, the big banks quickly cut back on debit card rewards. Instead, they moved to juice credit card reward programs, which tended to target more affluent customers. Credit card fees were not capped as part of the Dodd-Frank regulations.
Since then, the rate of credit card use has grown while debit card growth has slowed. Prepaid cards have been taking off but still lag behind those two.
Nevertheless, studies show that consumers prefer using debit cards to credit cards. According to a 2013 Consumer Payment Choice Study by the payments processing company TSYS, 49 percent of those polled said they preferred to pay by debit, while 34 percent said they preferred credit. Eleven percent said they preferred paying by cash or check.
Rewards ramping up
Instead of following the lead of major banks, some small banks and credit unions stuck with debit card rewards.
"In the last few years, many people expected to see a bottoming out of rewards offerings, but it didn't come to pass," says Ron Mazursky, director of Mercatur Advisory Group's debit advisory service. "Most of them seem to have kept the rewards programs going, because it's come to be expected by the consumer."
Smaller financial institutions generally have been slow to adopt rewards programs, but we've actually seen a ramp-up of the number of banks looking into adding rewards programs now.
Mercatur Advisory Group
In recent months, he says, he has talked to three or four times the usual number of small- and medium-sized banks looking to connect with vendors offering rewards programs.
"Smaller financial institutions generally have been slow to adopt rewards programs, but we've actually seen a ramp-up of the number of banks looking into adding rewards programs now," Mazursky says.
At Hanscom Federal Credit Union in Massachusetts, the institution's MemberPoints reward program has been popular with customers since its debut in 2007, says Steve Silva, the credit union's vice president of marketing.
Hanscom, with more than 53,000 members and $1 billion in assets, has stuck with the program because it seems like a good fit for the credit union's focus on offering an appealing checking account. Members earn 1 point for every $2 when they sign a receipt, or 5 points per transaction when they use a PIN.
The reward catalog offers a variety of merchandise. Silva says gift cards and digital downloads are the most popular. A $50 gift card to a Shell gas station or Lowe's Home Improvement goes for 9,990 points -- the equivalent of 2,000 debit card transactions or spending $20,000, which would be a 0.25 percent return. In contrast, the standard return for rewards credit cards available to people with excellent credit is 1 percent or more.
Getting poll results. Please wait...
"I can't say that this program really drives them in the door, but it's one of those added benefits," Silva says. "People say, 'Oh, really? I get points just for using my debit card, and I can redeem for a gift card or travel or merchandise?'"
He says he realizes Hanscom is bucking the big banks. "A number of financial institutions went away from debit rewards because they felt it was costly," he says. "We felt there was some value, and we return that back to the members."
Room for growth
Still, Hanscom is in the minority. Only about one-third of financial institutions offer rewards tied to debit cards, according to Aite Group research.
At Directions Credit Union in Ohio, Julie Linch, senior vice president of retail delivery, says the institution has signed on with national companies to run debit rewards programs. Consumers are increasingly expecting rewards, but they want other things, too, such as free checking.
"It's a piece of the program, it's not the main driver of the program," she says.
- 5 tips for choosing the right hotel credit card – Getting the most of these products starts with choosing the one that's best for you ...
- Credit cards compete to make you feel like a VIP – Travel credits, luxurious perks and unique materials aim to turn your and others' heads ...
- Rewards cards draw a surge of complaints to CFPB – Complaints about credit card rewards jumped 88 percent last year to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau ...