Banks drop credit protection plans
Plans drew fire as lucrative for card issuers but of dubious consumer value
By Tony Mecia | Published: August 27, 2012
Many of the nation's largest credit card issuers are scaling back their offerings of credit protection plans, following years of scrutiny by consumer activists and regulators.
|CREDIT PROTECTION PLANS WITHER|
What's happening: Big card issuers are dropping payment protection plans, an add-on product the cover debtors' minimum credit card payments under limited circumstances, such as the loss of a job. Critics have pointed out their payments are limited in size and scope and that card issuers' payout were puny compared to traditional insurance products.
In a survey by CreditCards.com, 6 out of 7 top issuers said they had permanently or temporarily stopped marketing the products, or altered them to make them more customer-friendly. Credit card protection plans, also known as payment protection plans or debt cancellation products, are marketed to credit card customers and typically cover the cost of monthly minimum card payments if the cardholder becomes unemployed or disabled. They are typically marketed by phone or mail to existing cardholders by outside vendors acting on the issuers' behalf.
Most of the banks said they were making the changes as a result of routine examinations of their business practices.
The pullback comes a month after the new federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau reached a $210 million settlement with Capital One and released guidelines for card companies on the additional products they market to cardholders. The rules don't ban credit protection plans, but they demand that issuers institute policies to guard against deceptive marketing.
The plans have also been the subject of lawsuits by states, which have accused some issuers of high-pressure sales tactics and failing to disclose that participation in the plans is optional.
The plans typically cost between 80 cents and $1 per $100 of your monthly statement balance. A report from the Government Accountability Office found that in 2009, consumers paid a total of about $2.4 billion in fees for 24 million credit-protection accounts. Companies paid back about 21 percent of that figure and took 55 percent of it as profit.
Card companies, though, have said that the services meet an important need and that customers like them. One card issuer told the GAO that its surveys indicated that more than 80 percent of customers using the service were satisfied with it.
Consumer advocates cheered the banks' moves.
"We've always said that these plans were really not worth the money that were charged for them," says Linda Sherry, spokeswoman with Consumer Action, a nonprofit education and advocacy group. "It is difficult for banks to make a buck nowadays, but it still has to be done aboveboard so we can trust the institutions that deal with our money."
Credit protection changes
Card issuers are changing their credit protection offerings. A sample of what top banks are doing:
|CREDIT PROTECTION PLANS DIE OFF|
name of plan(s)
|STATUS OF PRODUCT|
|Stopped marketing its plan earlier this year and is discontinuing it as of Dec. 31, 2012. "This was not a core line of business and was not a priority for most of our Cardmembers, therefore we decided to discontinue the product," a company representative said.|
|Bank of America
Credit Protection Plus
|Discontinued marketing these products in August and plans to exit the business, probably sometime next year. Company says it is "part of a broader strategy to streamline our business."|
|Reached $210 million settlement with regulators in July over allegedly deceptive marketing of the plans. CEO told analysts this year: "We have no intention to sell these card add-on products in the future."|
|Stopped offering new enrollments in October 2011. Continues to serve customers who are already enrolled. Change was a "straightforward business decision."|
Payment Safeguard, Balance Protector
|Says it recently "paused" phone marketing of these plans. Company says it is reviewing its procedures to ensure compliance with recent regulatory directives.|
|Still offers the product.|
Credit Defense Platinum
|Says it changed its credit protection product earlier this year "to make it more affordable and make it easier for customers to access their benefits."|
|Source: CreditCards.com Aug. 23-24 survey of major credit card issuers|
- Startups use tech to put cardholders in charge of security – With data beaches on the rise, startup companies are developing new options that help consumers minimize their exposure to a possible hack ...
- Which banks let you personalize your credit card? – If you've ever wanted to take you favorite pet with you in the in the grocery store or to a fancy restaurant, consider plastering their likeness on a credit card ...
- Voice assistants begin to answer credit questions – Voice assistants step into personal finance, answering questions about special deals and what you spent on your trip to Chicago. They can even pay your balance ...