Critics challenge retailers on opposition to interchange fees

By Jeremy M. Simon

Merchant opposition to the interchange fees charged by credit card banks has been a big news item in the world of credit cards lately.  Retailers have charged that these fees raise prices, with some having gone so far as to take out ads in newspapers stating that interchange fees end up punishing the consumer.  But according to some critics of the merchants, they do not have the best interest of the credit card user in mind when they oppose these fees. 

Many stores have asked the government to lower interchange fees, which the merchants consider to be too high.  In lawsuits and appeals to state and federal government, retailers allege that the method of pricing the fees is anticompetitive.  Merchants note that they have little option but to accept interchange fees for taking credit cards. 

The argument that the interchange fees violate antitrust laws (because MasterCard and Visa establish uniform fees for member banks to charge) has so far been rejected by courts, which have noted that there are other credit card and payment methods, and because of the efficiencies of this pricing system. Without the fee-setting method in place, the card processors say, stores would need to negotiate with thousands of different banks to process customers' credit cards.     

In Australia, such cost transfers took place when the government listened to merchants and set the fees.  After the price controls were instituted in Australia, consumers there encountered higher annual fees and fewer reward programs such as airline miles.  According to a study, 30 to 40 percent of banks' lost interchange revenues were simply passed on to cardholders via higher costs.  Local newspaper the Australian reported that these consumers experienced no corresponding decline in merchandise prices -- although Aussie retailers did save over $450 million in U.S. dollars.    

Critics expects that if interchange fees are lowered in the U.S., the same would happen.

Published: November 14, 2006

	Three most recent Merchant accounts stories: Merchant debit card swipe fees rise for small dollar purchases – Merchants that accept debit cards for purchases under $15 are learning of one fallout from the new federal cap on debit card swipe fees: Their costs will rise because the card networks have dropped the small-ticket-item discount ... How credit card transactions work – This interactive graphic shows what happens when you swipe a credit card, from the merchant to the processing network to the issuing and acquiring banks ... 5 steps to avoid ID theft at the register – Here are some steps you can take to make sure that you aren't victimized by credit card fraud when using your card in person at a retailer ...

	CreditCards.com's newsletter Did you like this story? Then sign up for CreditCards.com’s weekly e-newsletter for the latest news, advice, articles and tips. It's FREE. Once a week you will receive the top credit card industry news in your inbox. Sign up now!