Study: Payday loans trigger overdraft fees
High interest rates are just the beginning. Payday loans can also cost borrowers hefty overdraft fees when lenders try to collect.
That's the bottom line in new research from the U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
"We found that borrowers faced steep hidden costs in the form of bank penalty fees," CFPB Director Richard Cordray said.
About half of online payday customers missed at least one repayment during the 18-month study period, triggering overdraft fees of $185 on average.
The reason: Online lenders have access to customers' bank accounts, and submit payment requests over and over. For one bank account, the study found 11 payment requests in a single day. The typical overdraft fee is $34.
The study comes as the consumer protection agency prepares to put new rules on payday lenders and other costly short-term loans later this spring.
Rules first proposed in 2015 would cap rollovers of loans, or require lenders to verify customers' ability to pay. The study released Wednesday indicates that the rule may also limit payment requests sent to banks.
Online payday lenders get access to borrowers' bank accounts as their standard method of repayment. Storefront lenders may also get customers' permission to tap their bank accounts, as a backup for in-person payment.
Besides fees, multiple overdrafts can cause payday borrowers to lose their bank accounts, Cordray said. Over one-third of payday borrowers who were charged an overdraft fee lost their bank account, typically in 90 days. That left them at the mercy of costly alternatives such as check cashing.
The study found that online payday lenders often pinged customer accounts multiple times a day. They would break up the amount due in smaller pieces, hoping funds would be available. Thirty-four percent of payment requests occurred on the same day as another request by that lender. However, only 3 percent of subsequent requests succeeded when an earlier attempt failed.
In other words, lenders heaped multiple overdraft charges on customers, despite little chance of being paid.
"Of course lenders that are owed money are entitled to be paid back," Cordray said. "But we do not want lenders to abuse their preferential access to consumers' accounts."
With annual interest rates that average 390 percent, payday loans are scorned by consumer advocates. Earlier CFPB research found that a third of payday customers took out 11 to 19 loans a year. Congress capped interest rates at 36 percent for active military members under the Military Lending Act.
The payday lenders group Community Financial Services Association of America says that the CFPB's proposed rules would force many locations to close, leaving their customers without access to credit.
The CFPB said its study looked at 19,685 accounts at several large banks over an 18-month period. Each account had at least one payment request from one of 332 online payday lenders.The accounts paid online lenders an average of $2,164 during the period, including interest and principal.
See related: New rules proposed for payday loans
Published: April 19, 2016
- CFPB warning: incentives can harm consumers – The U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau issued a broad warning about sales incentives, possibly signalling a new enforcement priority ...
- CFPB: Minn. bank tricked customers into costly overdraft fees – Federal consumer watchdog charges TCF National Bank obscured fees and gave customers hard-sell to opt in for fees of $35 per overdraft ...
- FICO’s Scott Zoldi: Card-not-present fraud a growing threat – FICO analytics chief Scott Zoldi discusses the state of fraud protection amid the EMV shift and the use of trended data ...