9 tips for sticking to a holiday budget
By Lisa Bertagnoli | Updated: December 14, 2015
Here's one way to guarantee a happy new year: Rein in holiday spending. To do that, create a holiday budget and stick to it.
Financial experts advise you think of a budget as your financial GPS. Drawing up a soup-to-nuts budget helps safeguard cash, without quenching the holiday spirit: "It makes us a cheerful giver because we're not spending money that should go to another expense," Williams says.
According to an October 2015 survey by the National Retail Federation, respondents said they expected to spend $807 for holiday items (including gifts, decor, greeting cards, etc.) this year.
Holiday budgeting takes time, buy-in from the entire family and discipline. Here's a nine-step plan to make, and keep, a holiday budget.
1. Decide how much you can spend. Holiday money must come from your current disposable income. If you plan to spend money you don't have, prepare for a credit card bill that could take months -- or even years -- to repay. If you spend that $807 on a credit card with an 18 percent annual percentage rate (APR), and you pay the typical minimum payment, it will take you 45 months, and you'll pay an extra $305 in interest, according to our credit card payoff calculator.)
Ideally, you've saved some holiday money. If not, cut back on extras such as movies, dinners out or coffee drinks until the holidays are over. There are always things in a budget you can trim back.
2. Budget for everything. There are a lot of things people don't think about. Gifts, the cost of shopping (gas, parking), decorations, food and drink for parties, greeting cards, postage for cards and out-of-town gifts, travel expenses, holiday-related apparel and charitable contributions should all be in the budget.
3. Make a complete gift list with the entire family present. The list should include everyone -- relatives and friends, piano teachers and mail carriers -- who must be acknowledged during the holiday season. And don't forget the office gift exchange.
4. Decide who's getting what. For each person, set a firm "no more than" purchase price for that gift. Be realistic: $50 might be enough for a terrycloth bathrobe from Sears, but not for triple-ply cashmere.
If disposable income is tight, designate half the list as "card-only people" and specifying "make or bake" gifts -- cookies, pumpkin bread, handmade ornaments -- for 40 percent of the remaining recipients. Such from-the-heart gifts are welcome, especially if children make them.
5. Set expectations with family members, especially children. If gifts will be minimal, advises telling children now, to bring their expectations in line and absolve parents of gift-giving guilt. Now is also the time to discuss reasonable and economically feasible gift-giving tactics with family and friends, such as grab bags, name exchanges or skipping gifts altogether.
6. Start shopping early. Late November and December bring sales, but they also bring crowds and pressure to get shopping (and wrapping and mailing) done.
Donna Thomas-Rodgers, a leadership consultant who lives in Birmingham, Alabama., expects to finish her shopping well before "Black Friday," the Friday after Thanksgiving, the day the winter holidays traditionally begin. Thomas-Rodgers is shopping now and getting bargains. "Right now, so many items are on sale and nobody's really thinking about it," she says. One example: She bought her daughter a new bedspread, originally $50, for $19.97 at Target.
To stay within her $1,000 holiday budget, Thomas-Rodgers signs up for e-mail alerts from retailers to get a heads-up on big sales. She saves money and time and reduces stress by not wrapping gifts. And seven years ago, when her daughter was born on Dec. 12, she stopped giving gifts to family members. "I told them, I'm a parent now and my daughter is my priority,'" Thomas-Rodgers recalls. "They understood."
7. Check your emotions at the store door. "Gift-giving deals with emotion, and emotion and spending don't go hand in hand," says Ornella Grosz, the Atlanta-based author of "Moneylicious: A Financial Clue for Generation Y." To keep the feelings out of shopping, Grosz suggests keeping a list of other financial obligations -- credit card debt, car payments, mortgage payments -- on a slip of paper in your wallet. When tempted to overspend, remind yourself of what you owe.
Grosz also suggests shopping when pressed for time; less time in a store usually means fewer purchases. Shopping with a trusted friend who will firmly guide you away from the sale tables, and shopping with cash only can also help curb impulse purchases.
8. Work sales, don't let them work you. If a gift on your list is on sale, buy it. If it's not, "you're buying stuff not on the list and you'll go over budget," says Joseph Montanaro, a certified financial planner at USAA, a San Antonio-based financial services firm.
9. Keep track of spending. "Cash is king," Montanaro says. "It's very easy to stretch the budget with credit cards." He and others suggest "the envelope trick," giving each household member her or his holiday budget in cash, in an envelope: When the money's gone, it's gone.
If you use credit cards for convenience, hold a weekly reckoning with yourself, your spouse and your credit card receipts to make sure nobody's going overboard.
Montanaro suggests paying off holiday credit card debt quickly, in three months if possible. Yes, you'll still pay interest, but it won't be egregious. Consider the following: paid off over three months, $750 on a credit card with 18 percent interest will cost a total of $772.60. (Use the CreditCards.com payoff calculator to calculate your own scenarios.)
Your best bet: Pay it off in one lump sum. "Don't handicap yourself as you go into the new year," Montanaro says. "It's all about putting yourself in the position to be financially successful."
- Merry early holiday shopping: 6 ways to cut your costs now – Back-to-school and summertime deals can lead to major savings if you start your holiday shopping early. First step: making a budget and a gift list ...
- 8 strategies to resist impulse buying – Buying something new gives you a buzz, but can break your budget if left unchecked ...
- Stack card rewards with tax-free weekends for back-to-school shopping – Sales tax holidays and rewards cards cut costs on clothes, shoes, computers ...