5 steps to dispute debt caused by ID theft
If the debt is fraudulent, you don't have to pay, but you do have a mess to clean up
By Barry Paperno | Published: November 13, 2014
Speaking of Credit
Dear Speaking of Credit,
My mother divorced my father several years ago. He passed away last year. Last week we received a phone call out of the blue stating that she is going to be served with papers and needs to be home between certain hours to sign for them. We had no idea what it was about. I called the number given and they gave me info that she had outstanding credit card debt. I was worried this was the issue because my father had opened many accounts in her name that she did not know about. She has never knowingly opened a credit card account herself. According to the company, the account was opened on May 17, 2007, and closed in 2010.
They told me on the phone that she needed to appear in court one-and-a-half weeks from the time that I was talking to them. I told them it wasn't her debt, that my father had opened cards in her name. They tried to get me to pay money, I said no. We were never served that day. Four days later I was told that we were going to be served between certain hours. Again, no one ever came.
This is all new to me. Do I have to keep sitting at home waiting to be served? They were pretty intimidating, saying we were going to have to pay money every time someone came out to serve us. They said they had tried two other addresses. One was bogus and the other was a place she hasn't lived in three years. I think the debt is time-barred. The company was Chase. She lived in New Hampshire, which has a three-year statute of limitations. But now she lives in Massachusetts, which has a six-year statute of limitations. What do I do? -- Rebecca
No matter what scare tactics the collection agency tries to impose on you and your mother, she is not responsible for the fraudulent debt incurred in her name by your late father. As long as your mother follows the proper fraud procedures with Chase, you should be able to get the collection agency off of your back and clear her credit reports of any derogatory information resulting from this theft of her identity.
The first piece of advice I'm going to offer is, for now, avoid talking to any collection agency representative on the phone, making any arrangements with them or paying anything on this debt. Though your mother should not be held responsible, there will be some work to do.
How do you dispute debt caused by an ID thief?
There are five important steps to take:
1. File a 90-day fraud alert with the three national credit bureaus: Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. Filing a fraud alert will instruct potential creditors accessing your credit report to contact your mother directly before extending any new credit in her name. It also provides a free credit report from each credit bureau, so you can review her credit picture to determine the extent of the damage and dispute any negative information reflecting fraudulent activity.
While the main function of a fraud alert is typically to stop any unauthorized activity, the fact that the person who committed the fraud is now deceased eliminates that particular concern. For you, the advantage of the fraud alert will be to officially document the situation with the credit bureaus and obtain the free credit reports, which will enable you and your mother to check for any additional fraudulent accounts and start the dispute process.
2. Create an identity theft report at both the FTC (online) and your mother's local police department. These reports may be required by the creditor, collection agency or credit bureau to complete the fraud process and eliminate your mother's responsibility for the debt.
3. Call the creditors' fraud departments. Advise them that these charges in your mother's name were not authorized by her. Request that they remove any derogatory information from her credit reports. In addition, ask them to instruct any collection agencies to which the debt has been assigned to immediately stop collection activities. Your mother may have to provide proof of the divorce, as well as the police identity theft report, to show that she was not married to your father at the time of the account opening and fraudulent activity.
4. Dispute any unauthorized balances. Once you and your mother have reviewed her three credit reports, she will want to carefully follow the credit bureaus' instructions for disputing any unauthorized accounts. To prevent the chance of future abuse, she should close any open credit accounts she doesn't use.
5. Write to the collection agency. Explain the situation and provide documentation that will help support your mother's case. Any communication with collection agencies should always be in writing and sent via certified mail with return receipt requested. Under no circumstances should you or your mother speak with a collection agency representative, either by phone or in person.
Taking these actions should have you and your mother well on your way toward putting this most unfortunate experience behind you. I wish you and your mother the best of luck!
Meet CreditCards.com's reader Q&A expertsDoes a personal finance problem have you worried? Monday through Saturday, CreditCards.com's Q&A experts answer questions from readers. Ask a question, or click on any expert to see their previous answers.
- Q&A: How does credit card activity affect my score? – Making additional charges and payments on your card on the same billing cycle won't impact score; what really counts is how much you owe at the end of each month, and when you pay it ...
- Q&A: Best strategy to raise my credit score beyond 750? – The easiest way to raise an already stellar credit score may take some patience, but it's foolproof: paying on time and keeping card utilization low ...
- Q&A: Why a recent graduate should get a second credit card – A second card can increase your total available credit and improve your score; just look for a card that caters to credit-building consumers ...